FOLLOW US

America May 20, 2025 3 mins read

$2.7M Punitive Damages Award Nixed in Nursing Home Negligence Trial

America ı By Rochdi Rais

0 Comments

gardens-green-ridge

A Pennsylvania Superior Court panel on Monday vacated a $2.7 million punitive damages award against a nursing home and its parent company, ruling that the plaintiff improperly raised a new recklessness theory during the trial, catching the defense by surprise and undermining a fair proceeding.

The appellate decision stems from a suit filed against Green Ridge Care Center and Saber Healthcare Group LLP, alleging that their negligence led to resident Mildred Bernavage’s fractured hip. The jury in Lackawanna County originally awarded roughly $300,000 in compensatory damages and $2.7 million in punitive damages.

The three-judge panel upheld the compensatory damages but said the punitive damages could not stand due to procedural missteps by the plaintiff's legal team.

Recklessness Raised Too Late, Panel Says

The court's published opinion emphasized that Carolyn Vanston, Bernavage’s daughter and the plaintiff in the case, failed to raise any theory of recklessness during three years of pretrial litigation. The issue only surfaced during trial testimony, specifically in questioning of certified nursing assistant Virginia Czankner, who attended to Bernavage during the incident in the shower room.

Czankner admitted she had “gambled” with the resident’s safety, and when asked, affirmed that her actions were reckless. Other staff members also answered affirmatively when asked if their actions constituted recklessness.

That testimony prompted Vanston’s counsel to move midtrial to amend the complaint and seek a directed verdict under a recklessness theory, which the trial judge granted. The appellate panel, however, found this constituted an "unfair surprise" to the defense.

“There was no indication appellee intended to assert recklessness until appellee’s counsel examined Czankner at trial,” the opinion stated.

Panel: Recklessness Theory a New, Improper Addition

Judges Mary Jane Bowes, Judith Ference Olson, and Victor P. Stabile criticized the plaintiff’s tactics as a late-game shift in strategy that gave the defense no opportunity to properly prepare or respond.

“At the eleventh hour, appellee solicited the word ‘reckless’ from witnesses who could not be expected to understand the legal significance of that term,” the panel wrote. “The witnesses’ use of the word ‘reckless’... was of no legal significance until the trial court subsequently permitted appellee’s amended complaint.”

The panel found that raising a new theory of liability—recklessness—in the middle of trial violated due process principles and was procedurally improper under Pennsylvania law.

“We conclude that unfair surprise exists here, where a negligence plaintiff, without explanation, withholds the precise theory of recovery until the latest possible time,” the court held.

Plaintiff Plans Further Appeal

Attorney Jamie J. Anzalone, who represents Vanston along with Kelly M. Ciravolo of Anzalone & Doyle Trial Lawyers, told Law360 that they strongly disagreed with the ruling.

“We believe it is inconsistent with Pennsylvania law directly on point regarding this exact issue,” Anzalone said. “The trial court judge, now federal judge, Judge Julia K. Munley, authored a well-reasoned opinion consistent with Pennsylvania precedent on amendment of pleadings related to punitive damages. We will exercise every appellate right available to the plaintiff.”

Defense Yet to Comment

Attorneys for Green Ridge Care Center and Saber Healthcare Group LLP—Bill Mundy, Ira L. Podheiser, and Philip M. Mintz of Burns White LLC—did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Case Information

Case Title: Bernavage v. Green Ridge Healthcare et al.
Case Number: 1576 MDA 2023
Court: Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Original Trial Court: Lackawanna County
Presiding Trial Judge: Hon. Julia K. Munley (now U.S. District Judge)

Previous Article

Ex-Nightingale CEO Gets Over 7 Years for $63M Real Estate Fraud Scheme

Read More
2774 Posts

Rochdi Rais

Rochdi Rais is the Head of Growth and financial and legal writer at USA Herald. He has been writing and editing financial, legal and U.S. news for years with over +4000 articles published during his career.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America November 20, 2026 Anthropic Stock Slides After Record-Breaking IPO By – Jackie Allen
USA Herald November 19, 2026
Rosa Leyva Murder: Oregon Man Believed…

OREGON CITY, Ore. — Rosa Leyva, 61, was fatally shot…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 19, 2026
Dallas Police Department Faces Federal Lawsuit…

 The Dallas Police Department is facing renewed scrutiny following a…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 19, 2026
New Hampshire Auto, Home Insurance Reductions:…

In a year when many bills only move one direction,…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 19, 2026
GTA VI launch spotlights systemic cyber…

The GTA VI insurance risks are not about the game…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 19, 2026
Walmart raises its outlook for the…

Walmart raises outlook for the third time this year, but…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
Bed bugs force FEMA staff to…

The FEMA bed bugs story adds an unlikely twist to…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
Anthropic shares jump 21% after $107.3B…

The Anthropic $107.3B IPO opened with a bang on Thursday.…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
Binance Wins $6.5B Freezing Order Over…

The Binance $6.5B freezing order may be the biggest legal…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
Polaris $1M Data Privacy Settlements: California…

The Polaris $1M data privacy settlements show what happens when…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
 Anti-Death-Penalty Groups Intensify Fight Against Capital…

  The United States recorded 37 executions in 2026 as…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 19, 2026
43 Soldiers Unlock a GTA 6…

FORT STEWART, Ga. — The 9th Brigade Engineer Battalion offered…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 19, 2026
Lawmakers Press Lutnick Family Over Nvidia…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 19, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 19, 2026
Palmer Luckey Warns AI Hackers Are…

NEW YORK — Palmer Luckey says artificial intelligence is giving…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 19, 2026
Iowa Schools Cancel Classes as Army…

MIDDLETOWN, Iowa — Schools in southeast Iowa have canceled Friday…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
Government Investigators Find AI Platforms Generated…

Federal investigators found that four major artificial intelligence platforms could…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 18, 2026
Yellowstone’ Star Luke Grimes Opens Up…

Key Takeaways Luke Grimes admits he was worried about continuing…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 18, 2026
Florida Flood Threat: Record Downpours Swamp…

The Florida flood threat turned real overnight. Torrential rainfall and…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 18, 2026
Anthropic BIPA Suit: Illinois User Says…

The Anthropic BIPA suit alleges that a routine identity check…

By – Tyler Brooks
Breaking News November 19, 2026
Anthropic Hits the Nasdaq Today as…

Anthropic begins trading as “ANT” on the Nasdaq after selling…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 18, 2026
Is GTA 6 Out? Rockstar’s Blockbuster…

Is GTA 6 out? The answer depends on where you…

By – Tyler Brooks
Business November 18, 2026
GTA VI Is Finally Here: Rockstar’s…

Grand Theft Auto VI began rolling out at midnight in…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 18, 2026
Iran Says It Targeted Kuwaiti Air…

Iran’s military said it targeted Ali Al Salem Air Base…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
China to Lift 25% Tariff on…

SHENZHEN, China — Canadian pork processors lost roughly a quarter…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
Brazil Probes Whether Vance-Linked Group Aided…

Brazilian federal police are investigating whether Rockbridge Network, a U.S.…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
13 U.S. Babies Born With Measles…

U.S. officials documented 13 babies born with measles and 112…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 17, 2026
Katie Couric Reveals  Memory-Loss Episode That…

Katie Couric is opening up about a recent frightening medical…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 15, 2026
Hackers Hit America’s Drinking Water Systems…

ATLANTA – Hackers have crossed a dangerous line in America’s…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 15, 2026
America Loses Its Measles-Free Status for…

PAHO says the U.S. no longer meets the standard for…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 11, 2026
Brooklyn Building Collapse Kills 2 as…

A Brooklyn building collapse killed at least two people and…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
A Veterans Day Betrayal: House Advances…

OPINION | The Republican-led House marked Veterans Day by advancing…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 17, 2026
Content Creator Chrisean Rock Faces Looming…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald INGLEWOOD, Calif. – What…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 15, 2026
Tower Hill Investment in Gator Athletics:…

The Tower Hill investment in Gator Athletics just rewrote the…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 14, 2026
Golden State Valkyries Star Gabby Williams…

 Golden State Valkyries forward Gabby Williams believes Indiana Fever star…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 8, 2026
Dana White Reportedly Declines Trump White…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 8, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
Mike Tyson And Ric Flair Score…

Inside the $50 Million Legal Battle A federal judge rejected…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 5, 2026
Dallas Cowboys Face  Crisis After Crushing…

By Jackie Allen | USA Herald The Dallas Cowboys are…

By – Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter