FOLLOW US

Razor-Edge Insights

• Record-Setting Verdict Upheld: Missouri appeals court stands firm on a $1.5 billion jury award against Monsanto, refusing to budge despite seven aggressive appeal points.
• Glyphosate Litigation Tide Turns: Court rebuffs Monsanto’s reliance on EPA findings and affirms jury’s conclusion that Roundup’s glyphosate-based formula contributed to cancer in multiple plaintiffs.
• Precedent for Punitive Damages: The ruling reinforces constitutional grounds for massive punitive awards when corporations fail to act on credible health warnings.

Monsanto’s Appeal Fails

KANSAS CITY - In a courtroom drama that gripped both the agricultural and legal worlds, the Missouri Court of Appeals for the Western District has affirmed a trial court’s staggering $1.5 billion judgment against Monsanto. The appellate decision, issued under case number WD87059, echoes far beyond the Show-Me State, sending shivers through the corridors of agrochemical companies and their legal teams nationwide.

The consolidated cases involved Daniel Anderson (California), Jimmy and Brenda Draeger (Missouri), and Valorie Gunther (New York)—all with deeply personal accounts of how years of using Monsanto’s flagship herbicide, Roundup, allegedly led to devastating diagnoses of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

• Daniel Anderson, just 32 at diagnosis, told jurors he used Roundup for over a decade across California.
• Jimmy Draegerworked his Missouri land with Roundup, while his wife Brenda filed for loss of consortium, describing how their lives were upended.
• Valorie Gunther’snearly 40-year history with the herbicide in New York culminated in a harrowing cancer battle.

After months of wrangling—including special master recommendations on legal issues and evidence—the trial began in October 2023. The jury, after less than eight hours of deliberation, delivered a verdict that resounded like thunder across corporate America.

Eye-Popping Damages: Jury Sends a Message

The original jury awards included:

• Daniel Anderson:$38 million (compensatory), $500 million (punitive)
• Jimmy Draeger:$5.6 million (compensatory), $500 million (punitive)
• Valorie Gunther:$17.5 million (compensatory), $500 million (punitive)
• Brenda Draeger:$100,000 (loss of consortium)

Monsanto, now owned by Bayer, immediately sought to overturn or reduce the verdicts, filing a flurry of post-trial motions. The court denied most, but did reduce punitive damages to meet the Supreme Court’s constitutional 9-to-1 ratio. Even after remittitur, the damages remained colossal, signaling the court’s view of Monsanto’s ongoing conduct.