FOLLOW US

The Connecticut Appellate Court on Friday reduced a $1.44 billion judgment against Infowars host Alex Jones to $1.29 billion. The panel found that the state’s consumer protection laws did not permit Sandy Hook families to recover damages linked to Jones’ product sales. However, the court upheld key aspects of the trial court’s findings, including massive compensatory and punitive damages awarded for defamation and emotional distress.

Consumer Protection Claims Dismissed

The appellate panel determined that claims under the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act (CUTPA) were not applicable, reducing the overall judgment by $150 million. The court ruled that Jones’ speech, while offensive, was not strictly commercial and therefore did not fall under CUTPA’s provisions.

Despite this reduction, the appellate court supported the core findings of the trial court, stating the jury’s verdict did not demonstrate bias or improper influence.

Default Judgment and Damages

The appellate decision came after Jones challenged the 2022 trial court judgment, which included $965 million in compensatory damages awarded to Sandy Hook families and $473 million in punitive damages. The trial court entered a default judgment against Jones in 2021 after repeated discovery violations, a move he argued freed plaintiffs from proving their case.

The jury found Jones liable for defamation, emotional distress, and invasion of privacy stemming from his false claims that the 2012 Sandy Hook shooting was a hoax orchestrated by gun control advocates.

Arguments and Appeals

Jones’ legal team argued that the judgment was excessively punitive and that his speech was political rather than commercial, exempting it from CUTPA. Jones claimed his inability to comply with discovery was due to lost audience data after being de-platformed by YouTube and Twitter.

The Sandy Hook families countered that Jones profited from his false claims by selling products on Infowars and that his actions exposed them to harassment and death threats.

Broader Legal Context

The Connecticut judgment is one of several high-profile cases against Jones. In 2022, a Texas jury awarded $49 million to other Sandy Hook families. Jones’ company, Free Speech Systems LLC, filed for bankruptcy in July 2022, and Jones himself filed for personal bankruptcy later that year.

Next Steps

The Sandy Hook families, represented by Koskoff Koskoff & Bieder PC, expressed satisfaction with the court's decision to uphold most of the damages. Meanwhile, Jones’ legal team, led by Norman A. Pattis, may seek further appeals, potentially taking the case to the Connecticut Supreme Court or beyond.