FOLLOW US

Rugby commentator Stuart Barnes has lost his battle to avoid a nearly £700,000 tax bill after a tribunal ruled his contract with Sky Sports resembled an employer-employee relationship. The Upper Tribunal's decision on Wednesday upheld a previous ruling that Barnes owed the tax based on his longstanding deal with the broadcaster.

Tribunal Deems Contract Employment-Like

Barnes, a former rugby union star turned commentator, had his company, S&L Barnes Ltd., act as an intermediary in his contract with Sky. However, the Upper Tribunal found that if the contract had been directly between Barnes and Sky, it would have constituted employment, making Barnes liable for additional taxes.

Judges Thomas Scott and Mark Baldwin pointed to key factors in their ruling, including the exclusivity of the contract, Sky’s right of "first call" on Barnes' services, and Barnes' inability to delegate his work to a substitute. "The evaluation of all relevant admissible factors… leads us to conclude that the relationship would have been one of employment," they wrote.

Stuart Barnes £700K Tax Bill : Background on Barnes' Tax Dispute

Barnes worked as a commentator for Sky Sports for 25 years, between 1994 and 2019. He also freelanced as a writer and commentator for other outlets, including The Times and for major rugby tournaments like the 2015 and 2019 Rugby World Cups.

The tax dispute arose after HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) claimed Barnes owed £695,000 in back taxes for the years 2013 to 2019, arguing that his contracts with Sky made him taxable as if he were an employee. While Barnes won an initial appeal in 2023, the Upper Tribunal reversed that decision, agreeing with HMRC’s argument that the lower tribunal had erred in considering irrelevant factors.

Key Factors Leading to Decision

The Upper Tribunal judges criticized the First-Tier Tribunal for taking into account details such as distinctions between Barnes' roles as a presenter and commentator, the nature of his annual fee, and his involvement in non-Sky broadcasts. They ultimately concluded that the employment-like aspects of the contract outweighed Barnes' independent freelance activities outside his work with Sky.

HMRC welcomed the ruling, reiterating its commitment to treating taxpayers fairly. Barnes' legal team has yet to comment on the outcome.