UBS Loses Arbitration Bid in Charity Trust Dispute
America ı By Rihem Akkouche
0 Comments
In a blistering rebuke of UBS' litigation tactics, the Second Circuit on Monday upheld a New York federal judge’s decision to deny the financial giant's attempt to push a charitable trust’s mismanagement lawsuit into arbitration—declaring that UBS forfeited that right by wading too far into the courtroom waters before trying to pivot.
UBS Tried to “Have It Both Ways,” Panel Finds
The three-judge panel concluded that UBS “acted inconsistently” with the right to arbitrate when it first moved to dismiss all claims against it—without mentioning arbitration—before seeking it only after their dismissal efforts failed.
“Arbitration is not a fallback position,” the court wrote. “One cannot have it both ways.”
The panel held that UBS’ conduct clearly waived any right to arbitrate, emphasizing that their primary dismissal argument based on the Colorado River abstention doctrine—which seeks to defer to parallel state proceedings—was “particularly inconsistent with arbitration.”
Judge’s Ruling Affirmed: Trust Showed Arbitration Agreement Dispute
The Second Circuit’s ruling affirms U.S. District Judge Frank P. Geraci Jr.’s February 2024 decision, which determined that there was sufficient factual dispute over whether John Blair, a former attorney-trustee of the Peter and Elizabeth C. Tower Foundation, had the authority to bind the foundation to UBS’ arbitration clause.
Judge Geraci noted a genuine issue of material fact surrounding whether a 2006 agreement was valid in light of later trust charter developments. That question alone was enough to deny arbitration at that stage, he ruled.
The Suit: Family Ties, Alleged Abuse of Trust, and UBS’ Role
Filed in 2022, the lawsuit accuses John Blair—a former trustee and attorney—of manipulating the foundation’s elderly creators and steering assets under the control of his son, Jay Blair, a senior VP of wealth management at UBS. The plaintiffs allege this maneuver was designed to benefit the Blairs personally at the expense of the charitable trust’s mission.
According to the complaint, UBS “sanctioned” Jay Blair’s actions and prevented other trustees from exercising any authority over the foundation’s accounts since taking control.
The Tower Foundation, created in 1990, supports organizations in New York and Massachusetts that assist children and youth with intellectual and learning disabilities, mental health, and substance use disorders.
Panel Slams UBS’ Strategic Flip-Flop
The court criticized UBS’ litigation strategy as a classic case of forum shopping.
“They intentionally availed themselves of the district court’s authority... then sought to compel arbitration only after losing,” the panel observed.
Had UBS succeeded in its Colorado River motion, the case would have been dismissed or stayed in favor of state court—making any future arbitration attempt impossible, the court emphasized.
Discussion
No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!
FOLLOW US
Recent Posts
ZCash Security Scare Raises Questions About AI-Powered Cryptocurrency Exploits
85 Seconds to Midnight On The DoomsDay Clock: Why the…
The End of an Era: Seth Rogen and James Franco’s…
Intelligence Gaps and National Security Debates Following the Expiration of…
Digital Image of Former President Donald Trump with Unidentified Individuals…
The Pursuit of Biological Immortality and the Rise of the…
The Cheyenne Mountain UAP Incident: New Reports Reveal ‘Potato-Shaped’ Craft…
Don’t Miss It
30-year-old franchise: Pixar Wages War Against The Obsolescence Of Its Own Digital Legacy
By – Tyler BrooksPlane Crash: Twelve people, including eleven skydivers and their pilot, have died following a tragic plane crash in Missouri.
By – Tyler BrooksSteven Spielberg Disclosure Day Crushes Box Office Expectations As The Fight For Truth Enters The Mainstream
By – Tyler BrooksRainn Wilson: “The Office” Would Be Impossible In Today’s Climate Despite The Launch Of The New Paper Sequel
By – Tyler BrooksBackRooms: Hollywood Disruptors and the Rise of Content Creator Cinema
By – Tyler BrooksThe American Pop Star Oliver Tree Listed Among Fatal Helicopter Crash Victims In Brazil Amid Growing Aviation Safety Questions
By – Tyler BrooksUS Confirms Peace Deal: Hormuz Opens. Here Is What Happens Next.
By – Nicolas CarrenoOliver Tree Dies at 32 in Tragic Brazil Helicopter Crash During World Tour
By – Jackie Allen
Kelly Warner Law Firm Blames USA…
In what appears as a desperate attempt to defend multiple…
By – USA Herald
Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To…
Attorney Aaron Kelly and his law partner Daniel Warner are…
By – Jeff Watterson
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney…
USA Herald recently reported on a developing story involving Attorneys…
By – Paul O'Neal
The Pentagon Dropped Its Third UFO…
The files keep coming. And with each drop, the official…
By – Nicolas Carreno
Only 30% of Young Americans Dating
A new 2026 report reveals that only 30% of young…
By – Karen Jesena
New York Chaos Erupts After Knicks…
New York Chaos unfolded across the city after the New…
By – Jackie Allen
At least 1 dead, 10 injured…
The Midland Reckoning Sparks Absolute Chaos Across Texas As An…
By – Tyler Brooks
Tren The Aragua Reportedly Killed: Kinetic…
The order came down from the White House with characteristic…
By – Tyler Brooks
The Single Developer Revolution: How AI…
The screen blinked with a command prompt that signaled the…
By – Tyler Brooks
Shrinking Global Pipeline Threatens Financial Stability…
The classroom at American University Washington College of Law remains…
By – Tyler Brooks
New York Knicks End 53-Year Championship…
The New York Knicks have finally climbed back to the…
By – Jackie Allen
Paramount and Warner Brothers Merger Approved…
The proposed Paramount and Warner Brothers Merger has cleared a…
By – Jackie Allen
David Geffen Reunites With Ex-Husband Aboard…
David Geffen is making headlines again after being spotted spending…
By – Jackie Allen
Me Too Fallout Deepens as French…
The Me Too movement continues to reshape France’s entertainment industry…
By – Jackie Allen
Iran Agreed to US Demands: Trump…
In a major diplomatic development, Iran Agreed to US Demands,…
By – Jackie Allen
Iran Agreed to US Demands: Trump…
In a major diplomatic development, Iran Agreed to US Demands,…
By – Jackie AllenThe Me Too movement continues to reshape the entertainment industry…
By – Jackie Allen
Fatal Accident in Tulsa: Oklahoma Father…
A Fatal Accident in Tulsa that claimed the life of…
By – Jackie Allen
“You’re Killing Me” Brings Brooke Shields…
“You’re Killing Me” is one of Acorn TV’s newest mystery…
By – Jackie Allen
Karmelo Anthony Sentenced to 35 Years…
The case of Karmelo Anthony has drawn widespread attention across…
By – Jackie Allen
Trust Fund Battle Emerges in Rob…
The legal fight over a trust fund established by filmmaker…
By – Jackie Allen
Trust Fund Battle Emerges in Rob…
The legal fight over a trust fund established by filmmaker…
By – Jackie Allen
OpenAI Moves Toward Historic IPO as…
OpenAI, the company behind the wildly popular ChatGPT chatbot, has…
By – Jackie Allen
New York Knicks NBA Finals Game…
The New York Knicks took center stage during Game 3…
By – Jackie Allen
Cockroach Kingpin Busted: More Than 100,000…
A suspected “Cockroach Kingpin” has been caught in what authorities…
By – Jackie Allen
Skywatchers Events June 2026
Several meteor showers remain active throughout June. Skywatchers events also…
By – Jackie Allen
Sky Tonight App Highlights June 2026’s…
The Sky Tonight App is helping skywatchers make the most…
By – Jackie Allen
The Single Developer Revolution: How AI…
The screen blinked with a command prompt that signaled the…
By – Tyler Brooks
Behind The Walls A Public Figure…
The fluorescent lights of the visitation room hummed with a…
By – Tyler Brooks
The Reckoning Of An Industry Icon…
The music industry just witnessed a tectonic shift that will…
By – Tyler Brooks
Federal Ruling Shifts Legal Landscape in…
The gavel came down in a Manhattan courtroom on a…
By – Tyler Brooks
Elon Musk Triggers The Two Trillion…
The financial world stands at a precipice as SpaceX officially…
By – Tyler Brooks
Steven Spielberg’s Long-Awaited Alien Thriller ‘Disclosure…
Steven Spielberg, one of the greatest living filmmakers and a…
By – Rachel Moore
Nichelle Nichols’ Final Mission Ends in…
By Samuel López | USA Herald The woman who helped…
By – Samuel Lopez
Cannabis Giants Hit with Sweeping Class…
A major class action filed May 4, 2026, accuses five…
By – Samuel Lopez
New Pill Doubles Survival for Pancreatic…
Pancreatic cancer pill doubles life to 13 months By Tyler…
By – Tyler Brooks
FDA warns public as cookie firm…
FDA warns public as cookie firm rejects urgent recall request…
By – Tyler Brooks
Trump orders CDC to slash childhood…
Trump orders CDC to slash childhood vaccines from 17 to…
By – Tyler Brooks
USDA warns Americans over Salmonella in…
USDA warns Americans over Salmonella in meat products By Tylor…
By – Tyler Brooks
Mexico vs South Africa World Cup…
The 2026 FIFA World Cup is officially underway, but the…
By – Rihem Akkouche
FIFA World Cup 2026: Gianni Infantino…
The countdown to the FIFA World Cup 2026 has transformed…
By – Tyler Brooks
The Halfway House Showdown: Convicted Serial…
Justice. Accountability. Public Safety. For the survivors who faced Darren…
By – Tyler Brooks
Chinese Company Blocked from Claiming Olympic…
By Samuel López | USA Herald The Olympic rings are…
By – Samuel Lopez
Lawsuit Aims to Knock Out Trump’s…
By Samuel López | USA Herald The fight may not…
By – Samuel Lopez
2026 Stanley Cup Final Game 2:…
2026 Stanley Cup Final Game 2: A Thrilling Comeback The…
By – Tyler BrooksNo posts found.
No posts found.
