Jones Frames Case as a Free Speech Battle
Calling the $1 billion verdict a “death penalty sanction” on his media company, Jones said it punished his controversial speech without allowing factual examination. He claimed the families never proved falsity or malice, both required under Supreme Court precedent for defamation claims involving public figures.
He also referenced Justice Clarence Thomas’ past writings to argue that lower courts must follow existing First Amendment standards, even if some justices question them.
The Sandy Hook case originated from Jones’ false claims that the 2012 school massacre, which killed 20 children and six educators, was a government hoax staged by “crisis actors.” Jones later admitted the shooting was real.
Courts and Families Push Back
The Connecticut Appellate Court previously upheld the default liability ruling after Jones ignored multiple court orders, though it trimmed $473 million in punitive damages. The families’ attorneys called Jones’ latest petition “sheer gamesmanship,” accusing him of using free speech claims to delay paying damages.
Meanwhile, a Texas bankruptcy judge ruled that the automatic stay protecting Jones personally does not cover the assets of his media company, Free Speech Systems, allowing families to continue collection efforts.
