Based on the available evidence, the judge found that Musi had not made a compelling case that Apple’s decision to remove the app was unreasonable. Furthermore, Musi’s slow response to the infringement complaints contributed to the decision.
Apple’s Discretion Upheld
Judge Lee also rejected Musi’s claim that Apple violated the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The court emphasized Apple’s broad discretion in managing its marketplace and its right to enforce the rules governing the App Store.
