The bar further suggests that Supreme Court justices be given 30 days to review and potentially modify any decisions made by the panel before they become final. Additionally, NYCBA calls for justices to provide clear explanations when recusing themselves from cases, divest from publicly traded stocks, and avoid partisan affiliations with organizations like the Federalist Society or American Constitution Society.
Addressing Gifts and Ethical Standards
In response to controversies involving undisclosed gifts, the NYCBA proposes a $1,000 annual limit on gifts that justices can receive from friends, including hospitality. For gifts exceeding $250, the bar recommends requiring prior approval from the Court’s Office of Legal Counsel.
The report emphasizes that such limits would reinforce public trust, stating, “Justice is not for sale, and public service should not be a path to personal enrichment.”
Congressional Action and the Exceptions Clause
While the Supreme Court issued its own ethics code in November, it was criticized for lacking enforcement mechanisms. The NYCBA argues that Congress has the authority to pass legislation to ensure compliance with ethical standards.
