FOLLOW US

America June 4, 2024 5 mins read

9th Circuit Hears Objections to California Pizza Kitchen Data Breach Settlement

America ı By Rochdi Rais

0 Comments

9th Circuit Hears Objections to California Pizza Kitchen Data Breach Settlement

An attorney for objectors to a settlement between a class of current and former California Pizza Kitchen employees and the restaurant chain over a data breach told a Ninth Circuit panel on Monday that the district court did not properly scrutinize the deal or allegations of collusion between the parties.

The objectors' attorney, Theodore Walter Maya of Ahdoot & Wolfson PC, told the panel that the deal is worth far less than the $3.7 million valuation assigned by California Pizza Kitchen and the settling plaintiffs.

Problems with the settlement include exorbitant attorney fees for the class counsel, and that U.S. District Judge David O. Carter's orders approving the deal did not address the collusion allegations raised by the objectors even though the judge said on the record that he was troubled by them, Maya argued.

Judge Carter "never explained in the final order and judgment or in any of the transcripts why we shouldn't be concerned by these signs of collusion," Maya said.

Maya appeared to find at least one judge receptive to some of his arguments, as U.S. Circuit Judge Daniel P. Collins said several times that Judge Carter's approval of the settlement looked like a "rubber stamp," and that despite raising concerns during the proceedings about collusion, he never explained away those concerns in the written record.

"It's a complete rubber stamp," Judge Collins told counsel for the class. "He just took out the general formula, slapped it in the order, and we have no idea what he did with all that stuff that he developed over two days, he just didn't tell us."

"He made a great record, and the ruling is a cipher," Judge Collins added.

California Pizza Kitchen, or CPK, notified those affected by the breach in November 2022, after determining a month earlier that Social Security numbers and other information may have been stolen, the company said in a disclosure to the Maine attorney general's office. The company first discovered "suspicious activity" on its network on Sept. 15, prompting an investigation into the scope of the incident, it told Maine authorities.

Four lawsuits connected to the attack, which affected about 100,000 of CPK's current and former employees, were consolidated and included allegations that CPK was negligent in allowing the breach to happen and broke an implied contract with current and former employees to adequately protect their personal data.

The plaintiffs and CPK asked the court in May 2022 to approve a deal that they said had "a conservative value" of more than $3.7 million if even 2% of the class were to seek reimbursement for "ordinary" expenses of up to $1,000, and up to $5,000 for "extraordinary expenses." The group of objectors argued to Judge Carter that it was a "rotten deal" that appeared to be reached through collusion and ignored the potential of the claims under California's Consumer Privacy Act, which they valued at $77 million.

Judge Carter ultimately approved the deal. On appeal, the objectors argued the settlement "at most" could come to $497,974.50, with $800,000 in attorney fees. Although Judge Carter expressed concerns over the attorney fees and the collusion allegations during in-person hearings, the preliminary and final orders did not address those concerns, according to the objectors.

On Monday, Judge Collins repeatedly raised the issue of the order not addressing the concerns the judge expressed orally. Judge Kenneth K. Lee did not go as far as Judge Collins, but did say it looked as if Judge Carter didn't address his previous concerns about the attorney fees, while Judge Richard Clifton focused his questions on the merits of the case.

When Judge Collins asked Maya if the judge's order had an "articulation" issue of not explaining the court's reasoning, Maya agreed, but added that there is also a real "fairness" problem with the settlement as a whole "beyond any just matter of articulating what scrutiny was applied and the outcome of that," and that the settlement approval should be reversed and sent back to the lower court because it's overall a bad deal.

David Lietz of Milberg Coleman Bryson Phillips Grossman PLLC, who represents the settlement class, when confronted with Judge Collins' "rubber stamp" assessment, told him he agreed that Judge Carter's order "doesn't articulate with specificity what exactly he relied upon," but said if the panel looked "holistically" at the transcripts and full record of the proceedings it is obvious the judge developed an "extensive record through the court hearings and talks about why it is that he rejects the allegations of collusion."

Judge Collins disagreed, and said Judge Carter expressed various concerns and "then in the order, nothing. I don't know what he did with it."

Jon Peter Kardassakis of Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith, LLP, who represents CPK, told the panel that it's clear from the record as a whole Judge Carter "did take quite seriously these allegations of collusion."

"But I don't know why," Judge Collins said. "He said he was troubled by it, and then the next day he wasn't, and I don't know why."

Kardassakis responded that it was because of the "lack of substance" in the collusion allegations. He also noted that Judge Carter brought the mediator in to give live testimony, something Kardassakis said he'd never experienced before, and that the judge said he was "satisfied" with the mediator's testimony.

The objectors are represented by Theodore Maya of Ahdoot & Wolfson PC.

The proposed class is represented by David K. Lietz of Milberg Coleman Bryson Phillips Grossman PLLC.

California Pizza Kitchen is represented by Jon Peter Kardassakis of Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard and Smith LLP.

The case is Aviva Kirsten et al. v. California Pizza Kitchen Inc., case number 23-55288, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

Previous Article

Cali Appeals Court Upholds Decision Against Hooters in Server Harassment Suit

Read More
2774 Posts

Rochdi Rais

Rochdi Rais is the Head of Growth and financial and legal writer at USA Herald. He has been writing and editing financial, legal and U.S. news for years with over +4000 articles published during his career.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America November 15, 2026 The Orange County School Board approves health insurance plan By – Tyler Brooks
America November 15, 2026 Nonprofits sue five tech giants to freeze the AI arms race By – Tyler Brooks
America November 15, 2026 FAA Says No CyberAttack Indicated: Ground Stop Halted Saturday By – Jackie Allen
America November 15, 2026
‘Somebody Hit Us’: UPS Cargo Jet…

MIAMI, Fla. — A UPS cargo jet and a Copa…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 15, 2026
Supreme Court Agrees to Decide Whether…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Supreme Court has agreed to decide…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 15, 2026
America Loses Its Measles-Free Status for…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — For the first time in a quarter…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 15, 2026
Sean Duffy’s FAA Ground Stop Story…

By Samuel López | USA Herald WASHINGTON – The Federal…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 14, 2026
Worldwide Cyberattack Report — November 14,…

WASHINGTON – Cyberattacks are unfolding across the United States, Europe,…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 14, 2026
Rosa Leyva Murder: Oregon Man Killed…

OREGON CITY, Ore. — Rosa Leyva, 61, was fatally shot…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 14, 2026
Golden State Valkyries Star Gabby Williams…

 Golden State Valkyries forward Gabby Williams believes Indiana Fever star…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 14, 2026
Jensen Huang Lawyers Up With Trump-Linked…

SAN FRANCISCO, Calif. – Former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang has…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 14, 2026
Starship Blasts Off as FAA Outage…

WASHINGTON — SpaceX launched Starship from Texas on Friday while…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 14, 2026
Flights Grounded, Email Down: Two Days…

WASHINGTON — Two days of tech outages disrupted air travel…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 14, 2026
Three Nuclear Superpowers, One Table: White…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — President Donald Trump will sit down with…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 14, 2026
“A Miracle on the Mississippi”: Tanker…

NEW ORLEANS, La. — Passengers on a docked Mississippi River…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 13, 2026
Blue Wave, New Fight: Van Hollen…

WASHINGTON — Sen. Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 13, 2026
Logan Circle Shooting: Police Say Gunman…

WASHINGTON — The gunman in Thursday’s Logan Circle shooting waited…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 13, 2026
The Blue Wave Gets Bluer: Scott…

The Democratic blue wave grew Wednesday as Scott Colom defeated…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 12, 2026
FINRA Bars Minnesota Broker Who Forged…

The insurance wife signature forging suit ended the way regulators…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
SoftBank Loses $7 Billion as AI…

Key Takeaways SoftBank Group reported a $7 billion quarterly net…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 12, 2026
Zurich Insurance reports 7% rise in…

The Zurich 7% rise in P&C premiums landed Thursday, and…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 13, 2026
Who Was Guarding the Chips? Commerce…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Nvidia scandal that toppled one of…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 12, 2026
Pinion US to Acquire Catlin Specialty:…

The plan for Pinion US to acquire Catlin Specialty just…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
Elon Musk Says Hiring Jensen Huang…

Elon Musk has expressed interest in hiring Jensen Huang, the…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 12, 2026
Microsoft Outlook Goes Down Nationwide

The Microsoft Outlook down reports started piling up on Thursday,…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
Mark McGuinn Death: Country Singer Behind…

The Mark McGuinn death closes the book on a career…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
1 killed, 4 hurt in Logan…

The DC shooting began just before 8 a.m. Thursday, when…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 11, 2026
Brooklyn Building Collapse Kills 2 as…

A Brooklyn building collapse killed at least two people and…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
A Veterans Day Betrayal: House Advances…

OPINION | The Republican-led House marked Veterans Day by advancing…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 10, 2026
Vitamin K Deficiency Bleeding: Why the…

A single injection administered in the first hours of life…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 10, 2026
Infant Bleeding Surges as Vitamin K…

Infant bleeding rose as fewer newborns received vitamin K shots,…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 7, 2026
Can Elephants Sue For Freedom? Hawaii…

What’s at Stake for Mari and Vaigai A legal first…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
On Monday Supreme Court Weighs Whether…

What’s at Stake for Federal Prisoners A prisoner’s broken tailbone…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 8, 2026
Dana White Reportedly Declines Trump White…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 8, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
Mike Tyson And Ric Flair Score…

Inside the $50 Million Legal Battle A federal judge rejected…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 5, 2026
Dallas Cowboys Face  Crisis After Crushing…

By Jackie Allen | USA Herald The Dallas Cowboys are…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 4, 2026
WNBA: DeWanna Bonner Makes Emotional Admission…

ATLANTA — The WNBA Finals ended in heartbreak for the…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 4, 2026
Inés Gómez Mont Arrested by ICE…

MIAMI —  Inés Gómez Mont, a former television personality who…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 31, 2026
Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson Reportedly End…

Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson reportedly ended their romantic relationship…

By – Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter