FOLLOW US

America September 13, 2026 4 mins read

New Mexico Lawyer Fined $5,000 After ChatGPT Fabricates Witnesses in Murder Appeal

America ı By Samuel Lopez

2 Comments

Untitled

Key Takeaways

  • A New Mexico defense attorney was held in direct contempt after filing a murder appeal brief containing fabricated witnesses and false testimony generated with ChatGPT.
  • The state Supreme Court fined attorney Stephen D. Aarons $5,000, struck the appellate briefs and referred him to the attorney disciplinary board.
  • The case goes beyond the now-familiar problem of AI inventing legal citations because the filing inserted testimony from people who never testified—and, in several instances, apparently never existed.

By Samuel López | USA Herald

A New Mexico attorney who turned to ChatGPT for help preparing a murder appeal is now facing professional discipline after the state's highest court concluded that his filing contained invented witnesses, fabricated testimony and misrepresentations of legal authority.

The New Mexico Supreme Court on September 9 held attorney Stephen D. Aarons in direct contempt of court and ordered him to pay $5,000 to the State Bar of New Mexico Client Protection Fund within 30 days. The court also barred Aarons from appearing before it while disciplinary proceedings are pending.

The consequences did not stop with the fine.

The justices referred Aarons to the Disciplinary Board, removed his briefing from the appeal and directed the Law Office of the Public Defender to take over representation of his former client, Oscar Renee Sandoval.

Sandoval was convicted of murdering Shiereen Al-Jibury, his partner and the mother of his children, and was sentenced to life in prison in February 2025. His appeal remains pending.

AI Did More Than Invent Case Citations

What makes this case particularly striking is the nature of the hallucinations.

Courts across the country have already sanctioned attorneys after generative AI produced nonexistent cases or inaccurate descriptions of real decisions. Here, however, the errors reached directly into the purported evidentiary record of a murder prosecution.

According to the Supreme Court's order, Aarons admitted that his brief contained “false testimony from wholly fabricated witnesses.”

The court specifically identified Officer Michelle Amarillo, Officer Sanchez, Manal Al-Jibury and Teresa Marquez as fabricated witnesses. The filing also attributed false testimony to actual witnesses Danny Stanton, Linda Stanton and Mariah Chavez, including statements concerning alleged threats and the shooter's appearance.

The brief additionally misrepresented legal authority from two New Mexico Supreme Court cases.

That distinction matters. An invented legal citation can mislead a judge about the law. Fabricated testimony can distort what supposedly happened at trial—an especially serious problem when a defendant is serving a life sentence.

Lawyer Says He Expected a ‘Bulletproof Summary’

At an August 21 hearing, Aarons told the justices that he had supplied ChatGPT with a computer-generated transcript and other case materials because he believed the system would generate what he described as a “bulletproof summary.”

Aarons later told Reuters that he did not appreciate the extent to which generative AI could hallucinate information and characterized what happened as an honest mistake.

The Supreme Court was considerably less forgiving.

Its written order states that Aarons admitted he did not verify the factual claims or legal authorities generated through AI before signing and filing the brief. He also admitted that he had not informed Sandoval about those failures or the misrepresentations contained in the filing.

The court ultimately concluded that Aarons had demonstrated “a lack of remorse and a lack of concern for his client.”

Justice C. Shannon Bacon was equally pointed during the hearing, questioning how an experienced attorney could remain unaware of the highly publicized risk of AI hallucinations. Bacon described lawyers relying on AI hallucinations as an issue appearing in the news “every single day.”

The Lawyer Still Owns the Filing

The decision underscores a principle that is becoming increasingly difficult for the legal profession to ignore.

Artificial intelligence may assist with research, transcription, summarization and drafting, but it does not assume an attorney's professional obligations.

The lawyer whose name appears on the filing remains responsible for verifying the facts, checking the authorities and ensuring that representations made to a court are supported by the record.

The Supreme Court struck all briefing previously filed in Sandoval's appeal and ordered that new briefing begin under newly appointed counsel. The court said it intends for the appeal to be heard during its 2026–2027 term.

The disciplinary process could determine whether Aarons faces additional professional consequences.

Read the New Mexico Supreme Court's September 9 order in State v. Sandoval

Stay Ahead of the Story

Cases like this are rapidly redefining the rules governing lawyers, courts and artificial intelligence. For original legal reporting, consequential court decisions and analysis of how emerging technology is changing the practice of law, join the USA Herald newsletter and stay connected to the stories shaping the legal world before they become yesterday's news.

Follow USA Herald on X at RealUSAHerald.

Previous Article

China Expands Legal Reach Abroad as New Rules Challenge U.S. Sanctions Compliance

Read More
2036 Posts

Samuel Lopez

With over 20 years of experience in the legal and insurance sectors, Samuel applies his profound legal acumen to investigate and accurately report on the facts.

Discussion

CJ
Cohen Jared 2 months Ago

And there will be days when judges will be removed because they relied on Chatgpt in their rulings.. we are losing human judgment to an ai that only knows how to string words together

CP
Charlie Pott 2 months Ago

This is dystopian

Don’t Miss It
America November 13, 2026 Blue Wave, New Fight: Van Hollen Challenges Schumer By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 13, 2026 Logan Circle Shooting: Police Say Gunman Lay in Wait By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 13, 2026 The Blue Wave Gets Bluer: Scott Colom Flips Mississippi By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 12, 2026
FINRA Bars Minnesota Broker Who Forged…

The insurance wife signature forging suit ended the way regulators…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
SoftBank Loses $7 Billion as AI…

Key Takeaways SoftBank Group reported a $7 billion quarterly net…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 12, 2026
Zurich Insurance reports 7% rise in…

The Zurich 7% rise in P&C premiums landed Thursday, and…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
Pinion US to Acquire Catlin Specialty:…

The plan for Pinion US to acquire Catlin Specialty just…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
Qinetiq Sells U.S. Business To Serco…

The Serco $292M QinetiQ buy is a bold move across…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 12, 2026
Elon Musk Says Hiring Jensen Huang…

Elon Musk has expressed interest in hiring Jensen Huang, the…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 12, 2026
Microsoft Outlook Goes Down Nationwide

The Microsoft Outlook down reports started piling up on Thursday,…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
Mark McGuinn Death: Country Singer Behind…

The Mark McGuinn death closes the book on a career…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
1 killed, 4 hurt in Logan…

The DC shooting began just before 8 a.m. Thursday, when…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
Dan Hicks, NBC Sports announcer, dies…

Dan Hicks, the sportscaster whose voice carried golf, Olympic swimming…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
Brooklyn Building Collapse: Rescuers Tear Through…

The building collapse in NYC on Wednesday afternoon turned a…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 12, 2026
Ilhan Omar’s Former Bodyguard Was Indicted,…

A former Ilhan Omar bodyguard was indicted for lying in…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 11, 2026
Brooklyn Building Collapse Kills 2 as…

A Brooklyn building collapse killed at least two people and…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
A Veterans Day Betrayal: House Advances…

OPINION | The Republican-led House marked Veterans Day by advancing…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
Trump’s SNAP Cuts: What’s Law and…

President Donald Trump’s administration is proposing new SNAP cuts that…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 10, 2026
U.S. Soldier Arrested in U.K. in…

British police arrested a senior U.S. Army soldier Tuesday near…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 10, 2026
Oil Giants Earn $25 Billion as…

ExxonMobil and Chevron earned a combined $25.3 billion in the…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 10, 2026
Thomas Markle’s Latest Crisis: Meghan’s Estranged…

Thomas Markle, the estranged father of Meghan, the Duchess of…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 11, 2026
Rate Hikes Are Back on the…

A hotter-than-expected October inflation report has pushed the 10-year Treasury…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 10, 2026
Colts agree to trade WR Josh…

Josh Downs is officially getting the fresh start he wanted.…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 10, 2026
Insurtech Firm Reports Higher Quarterly Deficit…

Insurtech company Lemonade recorded a net loss of approximately $43.7…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 10, 2026
Senior US Soldier Arrested by UK…

A senior member of the U.S. Army has been arrested…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 10, 2026
Vitamin K Deficiency Bleeding: Why the…

A single injection administered in the first hours of life…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 10, 2026
Texas Man Charged With Murder in…

A cruise vacation took a horrifying turn when a woman…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 10, 2026
Infant Bleeding Surges as Vitamin K…

Infant bleeding rose as fewer newborns received vitamin K shots,…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 7, 2026
Can Elephants Sue For Freedom? Hawaii…

What’s at Stake for Mari and Vaigai A legal first…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
On Monday Supreme Court Weighs Whether…

What’s at Stake for Federal Prisoners A prisoner’s broken tailbone…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
Mike Tyson And Ric Flair Score…

Inside the $50 Million Legal Battle A federal judge rejected…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 6, 2026
Hackers Target French Blood Banks In…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald A cyberattack targeting blood-storage…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 5, 2026
AI Flagged Bias in Trump Climate…

WASHINGTON — Researchers on a Trump climate panel asked Microsoft…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 8, 2026
Dana White Reportedly Declines Trump White…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 8, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 5, 2026
Dallas Cowboys Face  Crisis After Crushing…

By Jackie Allen | USA Herald The Dallas Cowboys are…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 4, 2026
WNBA: DeWanna Bonner Makes Emotional Admission…

ATLANTA — The WNBA Finals ended in heartbreak for the…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 4, 2026
Inés Gómez Mont Arrested by ICE…

MIAMI —  Inés Gómez Mont, a former television personality who…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 31, 2026
Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson Reportedly End…

Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson reportedly ended their romantic relationship…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 29, 2026
Brewers Beat Rays to Win First…

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — The Milwaukee Brewers won their first…

By – Michallie K Harrison

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter