Thirteen Years of Delay: An Ethical Concern
Estate attorneys and probate specialists say that a 13-year delay in filing for estate administration is virtually unheard of, particularly for someone with legal training. Most estates are opened within months or a few years of death — not decades.
Such a delay can suggest concealment, an intent to misuse assets, or failure to discharge fiduciary obligations. In James’ case, the delay is doubly concerning due to her legal acumen and public office. Why would she delay estate administration until 1999 if the home had no complications?
Some experts speculate the delay may have helped avoid capital gains taxes, allowed her to collect rental income without scrutiny or taxation, and/or shielded the estate from potential creditor claims.
A Pattern Emerging?
The handling of her father’s estate has drawn renewed attention amid broader allegations of campaign finance irregularities and mortgage misrepresentations tied to James.
Critics argue that the contradictions in her estate filings, the delay in probate, and the lack of tax documentation demonstrate a troubling pattern: one that undermines her credibility as a top legal officer.
If proven, these discrepancies could trigger consequences beyond mere political fallout. Failure to accurately report estate tax obligations and property ownership may violate both IRS rules and New York tax laws — potentially exposing James to professional discipline, removal from office, disbarment, and criminal charges.
