FOLLOW US

America January 6, 2023 3 mins read

Florida Auto Policyholder Wins Big Against Insurer Who Acted In Bad Faith

America ı By Samuel Lopez

0 Comments

Untitled

USA Herald -- On the evening of July 4th, 2021, Florida resident Maria Hernandez was driving home from a family barbecue when she was involved in a severe automobile accident. Ms. Hernandez, a policyholder with Progressive Insurance Company for the past five years, was traveling on a busy highway when another driver suddenly swerved into her lane, colliding with the front of her car.

The other driver, who was later identified as Carter Clinton, admitted fault for the accident and was cited by the police for reckless driving. Ms. Hernandez, who was shaken but thankfully not seriously injured, immediately contacted her insurance company to file a claim for damages to her vehicle.

However, Ms. Hernandez was in for a surprise when her claim was denied by her insurer. The company cited a provision in her policy that excluded coverage for damages caused by "intentional acts," arguing that Mr. Clinton's reckless driving constituted an intentional act.

Ms. Hernandez, who had always paid her premiums on time and had never filed a claim before, was stunned by the denial. She contacted a personal injury attorney, who advised her to file a lawsuit against the insurer for bad faith.

According to Florida law, insurance companies are required to act in good faith when handling policyholder claims. This means that they must thoroughly investigate the circumstances of a claim, communicate transparently with the policyholder, and make a fair determination on whether to pay the claim. If an insurance company fails to do so, it can be sued for bad faith.

Ms. Hernandez's attorney argued that Progressive acted in bad faith by denying her claim without a thorough investigation and by using a questionable interpretation of the policy's exclusion clause. In addition, the attorney pointed out that Mr. Clinton's reckless driving was not necessarily an intentional act, as it could have been the result of distracted or impaired driving.

After several months of legal proceedings, a Florida court ruled in favor of Ms. Hernandez, stating that Progressive Insurance had indeed acted in bad faith by denying her claim without adequate justification. The court ordered the company to pay Ms. Hernandez the full amount of her damages, as well as legal fees and additional damages for the bad faith.

The ruling was seen as a victory for policyholders and a warning to insurance companies to carefully and fairly handle claims. Ms. Hernandez, who was relieved and grateful for the outcome, said in a statement, "I just wanted to be treated fairly and with respect, and I'm glad that the court recognized that my insurance company failed to do so. I hope this ruling sends a message to other companies to do right by their policyholders."

The case has also drawn attention to the issue of bad faith insurance practices, with some calling for stricter regulations to protect policyholders from such actions. It remains to be seen what changes, if any, will be made as a result of this case, but for now, Ms. Hernandez can rest assured that justice has been served.

 

Previous Article

Be on the Watch for These Illinois Cases in 2023

Read More
1987 Posts

Samuel Lopez

With over 20 years of experience in the legal and insurance sectors, Samuel applies his profound legal acumen to investigate and accurately report on the facts.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America October 19, 2026 An Airman Died After a Pregame Show. For What? By – Michallie Harrison
America October 18, 2026 Hunter’s Moon Illuminates October Skies By – Jackie Allen
America October 18, 2026 Alleged Chinese Agent Has Ties to Overseas Scam Group By – Jackie Allen
America October 17, 2026 America in 2035: A Nation Unraveled by Fascism and Oligarchy By – Michallie Harrison
America October 17, 2026 Flying Car:Elon Musk’s SpaceX-Inspired Tesla Takes Flight By – Jackie Allen
America October 17, 2026
Russian Winter Blueprint: Ukraine’s Heat and…

KYIV, Ukraine — A reported Russian winter blueprint outlines attacks…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 16, 2026
NJ Severe Thunderstorm Watch Covers All…

New Jersey residents are preparing for potentially powerful thunderstorms Friday,…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 16, 2026
Chubb And GKN Race To Opposite…

What’s Driving the Insurance Battle ACE American, a Chubb unit,…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
Katie Zacharia Fired After Less Than…

White House press secretary Katie Zacharia has been fired after…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 16, 2026
Recently Obtained FOIA Records Reveal AARO…

What the Pentagon Records Now Show AARO arranged a private…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
International Seaways To Buy Euronext Oslo-Listed…

International Seaways Inc., a major player in global oil transportation,…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 16, 2026
Cyberattack Supermarkets Shutdown Leaves French Retailers…

A freezer is supposed to be the most boring appliance…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
NFL Player $300M Hip Surgery Lawsuit…

Athletes bet their bodies on surgeons the way pilots bet…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Order To Limit Ukraine’s Use of…

What Readers Need to Know Zelenskyy answered a question about…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
Trump Fires Katie Zacharia After Five…

What You Need to Know Zacharia was dismissed after only…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
HealthSplash VP 18 Months Sentencing Rewards…

Cooperation can shave years off a prison term, but it…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Malibu Fire Forces Hundreds to Flee…

Wildfire in Southern California rarely asks permission. The Bryson Fire,…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Daylight Saving Time Returns Nov. 1…

Americans will turn their clocks back one hour on Nov.…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 16, 2026
Russian Drone Strikes Hit American Businesses…

Russian drone strikes against American-linked businesses in Ukraine are raising…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 16, 2026
Ilhan Omar MIA as Husband Flips…

What Readers Need to Know Federal agents seized Rep. Ilhan…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
Trump May Replace Susie Wiles as…

Susie Wiles, President Donald Trump’s longtime chief of staff and…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 16, 2026
California Ballots: Trump DOJ Targets 20,000…

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration sued California on Thursday, seeking…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 16, 2026
Starship Launches: SpaceX Seeks 456 Flights…

WASHINGTON — SpaceX wants permission for up to 456 Starship…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 16, 2026
Tesla Flying Car Roadster Leaps, Flips…

Most car launches involve a spinning platform and some dry…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Three Children, Teacher Killed in Oregon…

BEND, Ore. — An Oregon school shooting killed three children…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 16, 2026
iPhone Duo Buyers Face December Wait…

CUPERTINO, Calif. — iPhone Duo buyers faced delivery estimates stretching…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 15, 2026
David Surkamp Rock Singer Passes at…

Some singers fit a genre. Others bend it around their…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 15, 2026
Halle Berry’s Son Can Testify As…

Sidebar A Los Angeles judge has cleared Halle Berry and…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 15, 2026
Starlink Restrictions Hit Ukraine’s Drones; Musk…

WASHINGTON — Starlink restrictions disrupted Ukrainian drone missions this week,…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 15, 2026
Trump Scraps Hegseth’s Execution Livestream After…

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump canceled the planned execution livestream…

By – Michallie Harrison
America October 13, 2026
Pope Leo XIV’s Surgery Exposes Gap…

By Samuel López | USA Herald VATICAN CITY — As…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 12, 2026
Selma Blair Faces Issues After Alleged…

Selma Blair, the actress known for her roles in Cruel…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 12, 2026
Medicare Insurer Sues CMS After Star…

What’s at Stake Alignment’s largest California Medicare Advantage contract fell…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 9, 2026
Mother of Dead Russian Plague Lab…

What Readers Need to Know Darya Shipilova’s mother says the…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 9, 2026
Cornell Rape Case Raises a Difficult…

SIDEBAR Major research generally places demonstrably false sexual-assault reports at…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 11, 2026
AP Poll Top 25: Georgia Claims…

Georgia has reclaimed the top spot in the AP Poll…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 10, 2026
A.J. Armstrong: Former NFL Player’s Son…

 HOUSTON — Antonio “A.J.” Armstrong Jr., the son of former…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 9, 2026
NFL Pro Tyreek Hill Takes the…

What the Jury Is Hearing Lakeeta “Keeta” Vaccaro Hill testified…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 9, 2026
Terrell Owens Sued By Nolan Wells’…

What Readers Need to Know Three young men who were…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 3, 2026
California Sends Cease and Desist Letter…

What Matters in This Fight California regulators have reportedly ordered…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 3, 2026
Costco Faces $5 Million Sugar-Free Lawsuit…

By Samuel López | USA Herald Costco Wholesale Corporation is…

By – Samuel Lopez

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter