India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom

India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom
Dresden, Germany - October 24, 2013: Deutsche Telekom AG (English: German Telecom) is a German telecommunications company headquartered in Bonn and one of the largest in europe.The company has technical networks (ISDN, DSL, Satellite, Gigabit Ethernet, etc.) for the operation of information and communication services (ICTs), such as telephones (landline and mobile) or online services. The German Telekom employs worldwide 229 997 people, of which 68 276 employees in Germany. Office building from the Deutsche Telekom with logo on the facade.

In a dramatic verdict, a D.C. federal judge has mandated India to pay Deutsche Telekom AG the staggering $132 million in dispute following a satellite licensing deal fallout. Despite India’s invocation of sovereign immunity, the court has decisively dismissed this defense, marking a pivotal moment in the high-stakes legal battle.

Enter Email to View Articles


India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom : Sovereign Immunity Rejected

U.S. District Judge Richard J. Leon delivered a resounding blow to India’s defense, emphasizing that the district court is empowered to enforce the arbitration award. He rebuffed India’s arguments, citing established legal precedent and emphasizing the exceptional nature of arbitration awards concerning foreign governments.

Critical Exemption

Judge Leon underscored the significance of the arbitration exception, outlining the necessity to establish three pivotal jurisdictional facts: the existence of an arbitration agreement, an arbitration award, and a governing treaty. Deutsche Telekom successfully demonstrated the fulfillment of these criteria, consolidating its legal position.

India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom : Legal Fracas Unveiled

The legal saga surrounding the contentious licensing deal has unraveled a complex web of disputes and maneuvers. Antrix Corp., a commercial arm of India’s space agency, has been embroiled in its own legal battles, notably contesting a substantial $1.3 billion award in the Ninth Circuit. This convoluted legal landscape underscores the magnitude of the fallout from the licensing debacle.

Antrix’s Battles

The Ninth Circuit’s ruling in favor of Antrix Corp., overturning an earlier order based on foreign immunity arguments, adds another layer of intrigue to the overarching narrative. The $1.3 billion arbitral award, entangled with interests and complexities, sheds light on the multifaceted nature of the legal skirmish.

The Genesis of Conflict

The genesis of the conflict traces back to the ambitious plans of American investors and telecom executives to provide satellite-ground internet service in India through Devas Multimedia Private Ltd. The unraveling of the deal, catalyzed by alleged governmental pressure on Antrix to retract, sparked a cascade of legal confrontations culminating in the arbitration proceedings.

Deutsche Telekom’s Stake

With a vested interest in the deal, Deutsche Telekom’s involvement underscores the global ramifications of the dispute. Its acquisition of a substantial stake in Devas propelled it into the legal quagmire, ultimately leading to the pursuit of justice through international arbitration channels.

India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom : Final Verdict

Following years of legal wrangling and procedural intricacies, the final arbitral award, affirmed by Judge Leon, brings a semblance of closure to Deutsche Telekom’s pursuit of justice. The culmination of efforts, coupled with accrued interests and costs, solidifies the $132 million award, marking a significant victory for the telecommunications giant.

Awaiting Response

As the legal landscape continues to evolve, both parties remain tight-lipped. Requests for comment from counsel for India and Deutsche Telekom AG have thus far gone unanswered, leaving observers on edge as they await further developments in this gripping legal saga.

India must pay $132M Award To Deutsche Telekom : Representation

India is represented by Nicolle E. Kownacki and Weiqian Luo of White & Case LLP, while Deutsche Telekom AG is skillfully represented by Malik Havalic and James H. Boykin of Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP.