FOLLOW US

America April 14, 2023 3 mins read

Insurer’s Reluctance to Settle: Florida Family Awarded $7M After Tragic Car Crash Leaves Father with Life-Altering Injuries

America ı By Samuel Lopez

0 Comments

Untitled

(USA Herald) - My name is Samuel Adam, and as a legal news contributor for the USA Herald, I bring you a gripping account of a Florida family's pursuit of justice. After a life-shattering car crash in 2019, a Florida state court jury awarded more than $7 million to the Agnew family. This poignant story highlights the extent to which insurance companies will go to minimize their payouts, even when their insured has caused irreversible, life-altering damage.

The six-day trial in Alachua County focused on a tragic car crash at the intersection of State Road 26 and NW 143rd Street on June 13, 2019. The jury found driver Sebastian Harknett, who was driving a heavy-duty Chevrolet Silverado Keeler Roofing work truck, mostly negligent for the accident that left Thaddeus Agnew, a U.S. Navy veteran and father, with severe injuries. Agnew was driving his Hyundai Sonata when the devastating collision occurred.

Following the catastrophic collision, Agnew endured a stroke, loss of vision in both eyes, diminished cognitive functions, and other debilitating injuries.

According to Agnew's attorney, Jordan A. Dulcie, Agnew was driving home from work for Sysco Corp. when the accident happened. The intersection was under construction and had recently experienced rainfall, resulting in wet conditions. Agnew claimed the stoplight was flashing red, and after stopping and checking both ways, he proceeded through the intersection. Harknett, however, insisted that he had a green light and collided with Agnew's vehicle halfway through the intersection. Dulcie argued that Harknett was driving too fast for the conditions.

The jury concluded that Harknett was 80% at fault for the crash, attributing the remaining 20% of negligence to Agnew. Of the $7 million awarded to the Agnew family, Thaddeus Agnew received $5.9 million, including $1.3 million for future loss of earnings, $1.25 million in damages for past pain and suffering, and $2.5 million for future pain and suffering. The remaining amount was awarded to Agnew's family for loss of consortium.

As a keen observer of the legal landscape, I can't help but note, "The verdict amount, although significant, cannot truly compensate for the permanent injuries Thaddeus Agnew has endured. This case exposes the lengths insurance companies will go to pay out as little as possible, even when their insured has caused life-altering damage."

Keeler Roofing, as Harknett's employer, is also responsible for paying damages. Their insurer, Auto-Owners Insurance Company, held a $2 million insurance policy but stubbornly offered a mere $300,000 to settle the case before trial, despite Agnew's catastrophic injuries.

With the trial concluded, Agnew's attorney Dulcie indicated that he would pursue a bad faith case against Auto-Owners Insurance Company. This development is a testament to the Agnew family's unwavering determination and their legal team's commitment to seeking justice and holding those responsible for this tragic event accountable.

As this emotionally charged legal battle continues, I will be here to provide you with engaging and compelling updates on the Agnew family's journey towards justice.

By Samuel A. Lopez, Legal News Contributor for USA Herald

Previous Article

A New Harry Potter TV Series is Coming

Read More
1987 Posts

Samuel Lopez

With over 20 years of experience in the legal and insurance sectors, Samuel applies his profound legal acumen to investigate and accurately report on the facts.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America October 23, 2026 Lawyers Could Collect $1.27 Billion in Meta Privacy Case By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 23, 2026 Plutonium Pit Production Faces Safety and Cost Questions By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 23, 2026
Judge Orders Trump to Sit for…

MIAMI — President Donald Trump must sit for a sworn…

By – Derek Johnson
America October 22, 2026
Pope Leo XIV Needs No Further…

VATICAN CITY — Pope Leo XIV will not require additional…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 22, 2026
Six Women Testify in Russell Brand…

LONDON — Six women have testified in the Russell Brand…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 22, 2026
Websites Go Dark as AI Uncovers…

The PHP security crisis has pushed government websites offline and…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 21, 2026
El Nino Could Reach Historic Strength,…

GENEVA — El Nino, a powerful climate pattern that warms…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 21, 2026
News Overload Can Fuel Anxiety and…

News keeps people informed about wars, political conflict, public safety…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 21, 2026
Atlanta Rapper Indicted in Alleged $4.6…

ATLANTA — Shawtey Dred, the social media persona of Atlanta…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 21, 2026
Intuitive Surgical $450M Settlement Targets Da…

Intuitive Surgical has agreed to pay $450 million to resolve…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 21, 2026
Getty Images Files Chapter 11 With…

Getty Images Holdings Inc., the visual content giant behind millions…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 21, 2026
Meta Stock in Focus as Earnings,…

Meta delivered a powerful revenue performance in its third-quarter earnings…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 21, 2026
Pantheon $6B Secondaries Fund Marks Firm’s…

Private markets investor Pantheon has secured $6 billion in capital…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 21, 2026
Spartanburg Woman $8K Insurance Fraud Case…

A South Carolina woman is behind bars after investigators accused…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 21, 2026
Musk and Trump Have a Starlink…

Opinion | Starlink restrictions in Ukraine have exposed a problem Elon Musk…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 21, 2026
Texas Trans Texts Spark Election Propaganda…

News Analysis | Texas voters began casting early ballots Monday,…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 20, 2026
California Ballots: DOJ Cites Charges Against…

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department is citing charges against 28…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 20, 2026
Richard Riehle Dies at 78, Leaving…

Richard Riehle, the character actor whose memorable roles included “Office…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 20, 2026
Extreme Heat Is Spreading and Lasting…

An extreme heat event lasting 367 days touched nearly 85%…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 19, 2026
Information Ecosystem: Five Tools to Detect…

The information ecosystem is increasingly vulnerable to misinformation. There are…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 21, 2026
TDI Launches Insurance Fraud Task Force…

The Texas Department of Insurance has launched a coordinated push…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 21, 2026
Children’s Mercy Insurance Coverage Changes: Kansas…

Children’s Mercy Hospital in Kansas City will no longer participate…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 21, 2026
BioWare Closing: EA Shuts Down Legendary…

Electronic Arts is reshaping its videogame empire in a sweeping…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 20, 2026
Auto-Owners Insurers Verdict: Jury Awards Warehouse…

A North Carolina federal jury has awarded nearly $2 million…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 20, 2026
NJ $10M Car Insurance Fine: Geico…

New Jersey insurance regulators have accused Geico of overcharging motorists…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 20, 2026
Ara Partners $2.5B Energy Fund Reaches…

Ara Partners has secured $2.5 billion in capital commitments for…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
HealthSplash VP 18 Months Sentencing Rewards…

Cooperation can shave years off a prison term, but it…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Daylight Saving Time Returns Nov. 1…

Americans will turn their clocks back one hour on Nov.…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 16, 2026
California Identifies New York Life, Aetna,…

Key Takeaways   California’s Department of Insurance maintains an official…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 16, 2026
Three Children, Teacher Killed in Oregon…

BEND, Ore. — An Oregon school shooting killed three children…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 15, 2026
Trump Scraps Hegseth’s Execution Livestream After…

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump canceled the planned execution livestream…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 13, 2026
Pope Leo XIV’s Surgery Exposes Gap…

By Samuel López | USA Herald VATICAN CITY — As…

By – Samuel Lopez
America October 19, 2026
An Airman Died After a Pregame…

By Michallie K. Harrison | Opinion Tech. Sgt. Ian Patterson’s…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America October 16, 2026
NFL Player $300M Hip Surgery Lawsuit…

Athletes bet their bodies on surgeons the way pilots bet…

By – Tyler Brooks
America October 16, 2026
Russian Drone Strikes Hit American Businesses…

Russian drone strikes against American-linked businesses in Ukraine are raising…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 11, 2026
AP Poll Top 25: Georgia Claims…

Georgia has reclaimed the top spot in the AP Poll…

By – Rachel Moore
America October 10, 2026
A.J. Armstrong: Former NFL Player’s Son…

 HOUSTON — Antonio “A.J.” Armstrong Jr., the son of former…

By – Jackie Allen
America October 9, 2026
NFL Pro Tyreek Hill Takes the…

What the Jury Is Hearing Lakeeta “Keeta” Vaccaro Hill testified…

By – Samuel Lopez

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter