Several plaintiffs have already settled with Samarco, BHP, or Vale, a factor that Vale’s defense highlights.
The Epic Legal Saga Continues
This lawsuit, one of English legal history’s largest, initially got dismissed by the High Court, deemed more fitting for Brazilian jurisdiction. However, the Court of Appeal resurrected the proceedings in July 2022, recognizing the potential benefits for the victims in an English trial.
The Supreme Court in London, in June, refused to entertain BHP’s appeal, finding no substantial legal question.
The case’s substantive merits remain undetermined, with a trial slated for October 2024 to resolve procedural issues, including the applicability of Brazilian time limitations.
The High Court dismissed BHP’s plea for a trial delay, and as the legal saga continues, Vale remains tight-lipped, with other parties yet to comment.
Legal Representation
The claimants’ legal arsenal includes Alain Choo Choy KC and a team from prestigious law chambers, under the banner of PGMBM Law Ltd. BHP Group has enlisted Shaheed Fatima KC alongside a formidable team, under Slaughter and May Solicitors. Vale’s defense is helmed by Simon Salzedo KC and associates from Brick Court Chambers, instructed by Lawson Caisley of White & Case LLP.
