FOLLOW US

Tue

July 14, 2026

Opinion December 3, 2020 3 mins read

Doe v. Merck Could See SCOTUS Weigh On In Legality Of Mandatory Vaccines

Opinion ı By Carmine Sabia

0 Comments

Vaccination

With vaccines on the horizon for the COVID-19 pandemic, much attention has been paid to how the distribution will work.

Many have wondered if people will be forced by their employers, schools, or even entertainment facilities to take the vaccine and to have proof handy showing that they have taken the vaccine.

Which inevitably comes back to other forced vaccinations, like the MMR vaccine that one has to get before being allowed to be enrolled at just about any school.

A case that has been ongoing for a long time is Doe v. Merck which could now find its way to the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS).

The crux of the case is the argument by the plaintiff that the mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines caused his autism disorder.

The plaintiff believes that the MMR vaccine for Measles, Mumps, and Rubella that was administered to him in 1999 is responsible for his condition.

The attorneys for the plaintiff named the manufacturer of the vaccine, Merck & Co., along with several government agencies including Health and Human Services, HHS Secretary Thomas Price, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, and the United States of America.

The plaintiff argued that there was a violation of the National Childhood Vaccine Act of 1986 as well as fraud, and conspiracy to commit fraud.

The United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York dismissed the claim as “meritless” and said it lacked jurisdiction because the plaintiff “has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies.”

Now his attorney, Patricia Finn, has filed a petition for a writ of certiorari with the Supreme Court. A writ of certiorari is described by the United States Courts website as “a request that the Supreme Court order a lower court to send up the record of the case for review.”

On a crowdfunding website, the attorney said that their firm had “filed the most important case they have handled in over two decades of fighting to secure medical freedom rights for their clients.

It called the case “a culmination of years of litigation, and the hard work and sacrifice of all the families they have represented in the fight for vaccine choice and safety.”

“We now have an opportunity, for the first time in over 100 years, to argue the lawfulness of mandatory vaccinations that withhold exemptions for children, soldiers, health care workers, and many others, who are refusing forced vaccinations,” Finn said on Age Of Autism.

She said that the plaintiff now has to be placed in a group home where he will, again, be forced to be vaccinated as he was not able to obtain a medical exemption.

If the Supreme Court does take the case it could be groundbreaking. With a 6 – 3 conservative majority on the Court, there is a chance that mandatory vaccinations could be deemed unconstitutional, which would have a ground-shaking effect nationwide, not only for the coronavirus vaccines but for all mandatory vaccinations in schools and businesses. This should be a fascinating case to keep an eye on.

----------------------------------------

Have a story you want USA Herald to cover? Submit a tip here and if we think it's newsworthy, we'll follow up on it.

Want to contribute a story? We also accept article submissions – check out our writer's guidelines here.

Previous Article

Opinion: Georgia Residents Must Vote for Sens. Perdue, Loeffler in Runoff Elections

Read More
123 Posts

Carmine Sabia

Carmine Sabia Jr started his own professional wrestling business at age 18 and went on to become a real estate investor. Currently he is a pundit who covers political news and current events.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America July 12, 2026
two killed in Toronto After Deadly street festival shooting
By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 12, 2026
Elephant Fire burns 4500 acres in Sierra County
By – Rihem Akkouche
Arizona January 11, 2025
Kelly Warner Law Firm Blames USA…

In what appears as a desperate attempt to defend multiple…

By – USA Herald
Arizona January 4, 2025
Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To…

Attorney Aaron Kelly and his law partner Daniel Warner are…

By – Jeff Watterson
Arizona December 12, 2024
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney…

USA Herald recently reported on a developing story involving Attorneys…

By – Paul O'Neal
America July 11, 2026
1 dead After fire at Davis…

A Saturday morning that began like any other in South…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
Apple Sues OpenAI Over Trade Secrets…

The partnership that placed ChatGPT inside hundreds of millions of…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
NYT Air Force One Subpoena Targets…

They came on a Friday evening, to the homes of…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
Gordie Howe Bridge to Open on…

Named for a hockey legend who won four Stanley Cups…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
Teen Football Player’s Death on Uninhabited…

Christine and Elmore Wonsley are not sleeping. They cannot. A…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
Hundreds Of People at Summer Camp…

The water came faster than the roads could handle and…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
Hundreds Of People at Summer Camp…

The water came faster than the roads could handle and…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 11, 2026
UFC Event Allegedly Targeted in White…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — A historic UFC Event held on the…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 10, 2026
Russia Sanctions Bill Gains BiPartisan as…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Russia Sanctions legislation moved closer to becoming…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 10, 2026
Manhattanhenge 2026: Final Summer Sunset Alignment…

NEW YORK — Manhattanhenge is making its final appearance of…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 10, 2026
Jared Isaacman Says NASA Has Unexplained…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Jared Isaacman, the administrator of NASA, says…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 9, 2026
Erika Kirk Seeks Public Release of…

Erika Kirk, the widow of Turning Point USA co-founder Charlie…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 9, 2026
Erika Kirk Seeks Public Release of…

Erika Kirk, the widow of Turning Point USA co-founder Charlie…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 9, 2026
Bonnie Tyler Remembered as Legendary Welsh…

Bonnie Tyler, the Welsh singer whose unmistakable raspy voice powered…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 9, 2026
Assault on Iran Escalates as U.S.…

The Assault on Iran intensified after the United States launched…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 9, 2026
Broadcom Deal: Apple Commits More Than…

Apple is dramatically expanding its investment in American semiconductor manufacturing…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 8, 2026
Arranged Marriage Ends in Tragedy: Amazon…

An Arranged Marriage that began in the summer of 2025…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 8, 2026
Forensic Scientist Henry Lee’s Final Interview…

A legendary Forensic Scientist whose testimony influenced some of America’s…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 8, 2026
Forensic Scientist Henry Lee’s Final Interview…

A legendary Forensic Scientist whose testimony influenced some of America’s…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 6, 2026
Accused of Rape:  Graham Platner Denies…

Accused of Rape, Maine Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Graham Platner…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 6, 2026
AI Regulation Debate Intensifies After Peter…

 The global debate over AI Regulation took a dramatic turn…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 5, 2026
California Chaos: Fourth of July Celebrations…

California Chaos unfolded across parts of Southern California during the…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 5, 2026
Paul Pelosi Faces Charge After Alleged…

Paul Pelosi, the husband of former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi,…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 4, 2026
Beach Closures Expand Across Long Island…

Beach Closures were spread across parts of New York just…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 4, 2026
Beach Closures Expand Across Long Island…

Beach Closures were spread across parts of New York just…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 3, 2026
Mars Rover Images Lead to Debates…

A new Mars Rover image captured by NASA’s Curiosity mission…

By – Jackie Allen
America July 3, 2026
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s Star-Studded…

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s highly anticipated wedding is finally…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America July 3, 2026
Federal Judge Sends Bad Bunny Reggaeton…

INSIDE THIS REPORT A federal judge denied summary judgment to…

By – Samuel Lopez
America July 3, 2026
Mike Rowe Sues Discovery for $2…

Inside This Report Mike Rowe is suing Discovery, claiming the…

By – Samuel Lopez
America July 3, 2026
7-Eleven Sues Nike Over Alleged Air…

INSIDE THIS REPORT Nike faces a federal trademark lawsuit over…

By – Samuel Lopez
Health July 2, 2026
The Hidden Science Behind Why Your…

For millions of people, the first conscious act of the…

By – Tyler Brooks
Health July 2, 2026
The High Cost of the Infinite…

A significant legal chapter is closing for one of the…

By – Tyler Brooks
Health July 2, 2026
Kentucky Medicaid Alert How The Upcoming…

A significant change is arriving for thousands of Kentucky residents…

By – Tyler Brooks
Health June 29, 2026
Everything You Need to Know About…

As the calendar turns to July 1, residents of Georgia…

By – Tyler Brooks
Breaking News June 26, 2026
Trump Seeks $1.4 Billion as Congo…

The Trump Ebola funding request would provide more than $1.4…

By – Michallie Harrison
Health June 25, 2026
Temperatures in France were higher than…

The images coming out of Europe this week are nothing…

By – Tyler Brooks
America July 2, 2026
Taylor Swift Wedding Reports Claim Private…

Taylor Swift Wedding speculation intensified after reports claimed that pop…

By – Jackie Allen
High Profile Court Cases July 2, 2026
Justice Served as Former NFL Scout…

The Nashville courtroom fell silent this Wednesday as a jury…

By – Tyler Brooks
America June 29, 2026
Stonewall Riots: An Uprising That Changed…

The Stonewall Riots marked one of the most significant turning…

By – Jackie Allen
Sports June 26, 2026
USMNT Lost to Turkey at 90+8.…

Kaan Ayhan’s goal came in the 90th minute, plus eight.…

By – Nicolas Carreno
Entertainment June 25, 2026
Tears, Goals, and the Siuuu: IShowSpeed’s…

The 2026 FIFA World Cup has been a rollercoaster of…

By – Tyler Brooks
America June 22, 2026
World Cup History Made as Lionel…

World Cup history was made Monday afternoon in Arlington, Texas,…

By – Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter