FOLLOW US

Opinion December 3, 2020 3 mins read

Doe v. Merck Could See SCOTUS Weigh On In Legality Of Mandatory Vaccines

Opinion ı By Carmine Sabia

0 Comments

Vaccination

With vaccines on the horizon for the COVID-19 pandemic, much attention has been paid to how the distribution will work.

Many have wondered if people will be forced by their employers, schools, or even entertainment facilities to take the vaccine and to have proof handy showing that they have taken the vaccine.

Which inevitably comes back to other forced vaccinations, like the MMR vaccine that one has to get before being allowed to be enrolled at just about any school.

A case that has been ongoing for a long time is Doe v. Merck which could now find its way to the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS).

The crux of the case is the argument by the plaintiff that the mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines caused his autism disorder.

The plaintiff believes that the MMR vaccine for Measles, Mumps, and Rubella that was administered to him in 1999 is responsible for his condition.

The attorneys for the plaintiff named the manufacturer of the vaccine, Merck & Co., along with several government agencies including Health and Human Services, HHS Secretary Thomas Price, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, and the United States of America.

The plaintiff argued that there was a violation of the National Childhood Vaccine Act of 1986 as well as fraud, and conspiracy to commit fraud.

The United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York dismissed the claim as “meritless” and said it lacked jurisdiction because the plaintiff “has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies.”

Now his attorney, Patricia Finn, has filed a petition for a writ of certiorari with the Supreme Court. A writ of certiorari is described by the United States Courts website as “a request that the Supreme Court order a lower court to send up the record of the case for review.”

On a crowdfunding website, the attorney said that their firm had “filed the most important case they have handled in over two decades of fighting to secure medical freedom rights for their clients.

It called the case “a culmination of years of litigation, and the hard work and sacrifice of all the families they have represented in the fight for vaccine choice and safety.”

“We now have an opportunity, for the first time in over 100 years, to argue the lawfulness of mandatory vaccinations that withhold exemptions for children, soldiers, health care workers, and many others, who are refusing forced vaccinations,” Finn said on Age Of Autism.

She said that the plaintiff now has to be placed in a group home where he will, again, be forced to be vaccinated as he was not able to obtain a medical exemption.

If the Supreme Court does take the case it could be groundbreaking. With a 6 – 3 conservative majority on the Court, there is a chance that mandatory vaccinations could be deemed unconstitutional, which would have a ground-shaking effect nationwide, not only for the coronavirus vaccines but for all mandatory vaccinations in schools and businesses. This should be a fascinating case to keep an eye on.

----------------------------------------

Have a story you want USA Herald to cover? Submit a tip here and if we think it's newsworthy, we'll follow up on it.

Want to contribute a story? We also accept article submissions – check out our writer's guidelines here.

Previous Article

Opinion: Georgia Residents Must Vote for Sens. Perdue, Loeffler in Runoff Elections

Read More
123 Posts

Carmine Sabia

Carmine Sabia Jr started his own professional wrestling business at age 18 and went on to become a real estate investor. Currently he is a pundit who covers political news and current events.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
High Profile Court Cases September 13, 2026
CIA Gold Bar Case Nears Plea Deal Amid Classified Evidence
By – Michallie Harrison
International September 12, 2026
Saudi Pipeline Shutdown Threatens a Deeper Fuel Crisis
By – Michallie Harrison
America September 11, 2026
$LAPTOP Meme Coin Crashes After Hunter Biden Launches Cryptocurrency
By – Jackie Allen
America September 11, 2026
Silverthorne Bomb Threat Triggers Evacuations, School Transport Chaos
By – Rihem Akkouche
America September 11, 2026
Arrow Bank to Acquire Skene Valley in Upstate New York Insurance Deal
By – Rihem Akkouche
America September 11, 2026
Tenet Health 1,500 Layoffs Ripple Across…

Job losses rarely arrive in isolation — they tend to…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America September 11, 2026
Bears and RB Swift $33.75M Extension…

Sometimes the best deals get done before the clock even…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
New Mexico Atty $5K Fine Follows…

Courtrooms run on facts, testimony and citations that can withstand…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
Ryan Ryan $60M Malpractice Lawsuit Accuses…

Sometimes the most expensive mistake isn’t what a lawyer says…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
Cooley, Investor Malpractice Suit Settlement Closes…

Startups often promise disruption — a fresh spin on an…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
Conduent Data Breach Claims Settlement Ends…

A data breach is bad enough on its own —…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
Conduent Data Breach Claims Settlement Ends…

A data breach is bad enough on its own —…

By – Tyler Brooks
America September 11, 2026
Skywatcher: ExoMoon Discovery May Reveal First…

An ExoMoon discovery may have given astronomers their first confirmed…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 11, 2026
Skywatchers: Moonshadow Creates Dramatic Blood Moon…

A Moonshadow transformed the night sky Aug. 27 as the…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 11, 2026
Josh Hawley Opens OpenAI Investigation Over…

Key Takeaways Josh Hawley is demanding answers and internal records…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 11, 2026
Congress Has Seen the Evidence on…

Key Takeaways Lawmakers with security clearances, including Rep. Nancy Mace,…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 11, 2026
Mexican Food Company Announces California Layoffs…

Key Takeaways Ruiz Foods is cutting 176 jobs at its…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 10, 2026
Flock Safety Cracks Down on Police…

Flock Safety is introducing mandatory safeguards for its automated license-plate…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 10, 2026
OpenAI Cybersecurity Under Scrutiny After AI…

OpenAI cybersecurity concerns are growing after researchers reported that a…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 9, 2026
To Catch a Predator: Robert Pattinson…

The phrase Catch a Predator became synonymous with one of…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 8, 2026
Trump-a-Palooza: Republicans Put Trump at Center…

DALLAS — Trump-a-Palooza is bringing Republicans from across the country…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 8, 2026
Iranian Twins Face Death Sentence and…

Iranian twins Taraneh and Romina Rahimi, 20, are facing drastically…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 8, 2026
AI Amnesia: Bigger Diffusion Models May…

AI Amnesia may be an emerging problem for researchers, artists…

By – Jackie Allen
America September 11, 2026
Mexican Food Company Announces California Layoffs…

Key Takeaways Ruiz Foods is cutting 176 jobs at its…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 10, 2026
Massachusetts Judge Publicly Reprimanded Over 2018…

Key Takeaways The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court publicly reprimanded Judge…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 10, 2026
Anthropic Says It Caught Scientists Trying…

Key Takeaways Anthropic’s newest threat intelligence report details five case…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 10, 2026
Michael Jackson Accuser James Safechuck and…

Key Takeaways James Safechuck is reportedly scheduled for questioning September…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 10, 2026
Latham Buys Nvidia Servers to Power…

Most law firms borrow their horsepower — leasing AI tools…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America September 10, 2026
PGR Filed for Bankruptcy as Solar…

Solar power promises endless energy from an endless source —…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America September 10, 2026
Wrongful Death Lawsuit Against Energy Drink…

Key takeaways The latest reported order paused the family’s lawsuit…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 9, 2026
Ambient AI Could Be the Next…

Key Takeaways Ambient AI can turn conversations into draft records,…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 5, 2026
Georgian National Indicted in Money Laundering…

By Samuel López | USA Herald A federal grand jury…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 1, 2026
DOJ Drops Hammer On Kansas School…

By Samuel López | USA Herald The U.S. Department of…

By – Samuel Lopez
America August 28, 2026
CVS Ordered to Answer for AI-Fueled…

Case at a Glance A Manhattan federal judge has ruled…

By – Samuel Lopez
Breaking News August 27, 2026
Sacred Horse Year Pilgrimage Turns Catastrophic…

A Disaster Unfolding in Real Time, Legal and Diplomatic Fallout…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 6, 2026
Travis Kelce-Backed Club Car Wash Faces…

By Samuel López | USA Herald A fast-growing car wash…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 6, 2026
‘DWTS’ Gleb Savchenko Lists $1.4 Million…

By Samuel López | USA Herald Factual Background Gleb Savchenko…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 4, 2026
Trump Calls Tiger Woods DUI Plea…

In This Report Tiger Woods accepted reduced charges and surrendered…

By – Samuel Lopez
America September 2, 2026
Clippers Fined $30M as NBA Drops…

A year-long investigation just landed on the Los Angeles Clippers…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America August 26, 2026
Tupac Shakur Murder Trial Moves to…

The Tupac Shakur murder trial will resume Thursday in Las…

By – Jackie Allen
America August 21, 2026
World Cup Brawl Leads to Major…

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. — The World Cup final between Spain…

By – Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter