FOLLOW US

  • facebook
  • twitter
Mon

March 9, 2026

America July 1, 2023

Gorsuch Counters Sotomayor’s Remarks: First Amendment Rights the Issue in LGBT Case

America ı By Jackie Allen

376 0 Comments

In a recent Supreme Court ruling, Justice Neil Gorsuch came under fire from his liberal colleague, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, for allegedly relegating LGBT individuals to "second-class status." Gorsuch insisted everyone’s first amendment rights were equal.  The case in question, 303 Creative v. Elenis, dealt with a Colorado web designer, Lorie Smith, who refused to include certain messages on websites for same-sex couples based on her sincere Christian beliefs.  Gorsuch, writing the 6-3 majority opinion, firmly rebuked Sotomayor's dissent, highlighting what he believed to be distortions of the case's facts. According to Sotomayor, the majority's decision granted a "new license to discriminate" and marginalized the LGBT community. She argued that the ruling had the immediate effect of branding gays and lesbians as second-class citizens.  However, Gorsuch vehemently disagreed, asserting that Sotomayor had mischaracterized the nature of the case and had gone so far as to contradict her own position. He added that it "reimagines the facts of this case from top to bottom." "In some places, the dissent gets so turned around about the facts that it opens fire on its own position," Gorsuch wrote.  "For instance: While stressing that a Colorado company cannot refuse ‘the full and equal enjoyment of [its] services’ based on a customer’s protected status … the dissent assures us that a company selling creative services ‘to the public’ does have a right ‘to decide what messages to include or not to include …' But if that is true, what are we even debating?"

Free Speech Issues

Gorsuch argued that the dissent engaged in speculation and hypotheticals rather than focusing on the core elements of the case at hand.  He questioned why the dissent was fixated on including or excluding messages in creative services when the case revolved around a web designer's First Amendment rights.  Gorsuch further emphasized that the majority's decision was not a condemnation of public accommodation laws but a defense of individual freedom and tolerance. Joining Sotomayor in dissent were Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, both appointed by Democratic presidents. Sotomayor contended that the majority's opinion perpetuated social hierarchies and went against the principles underlying public accommodations laws.  She urged a broader interpretation of the law, emphasizing that a democratic society should prioritize equality and reject coercion. In contrast, Gorsuch and the five other Republican-appointed justices found the majority's decision consistent with the First Amendment. 
12

Previous Article

Russian Sudden Death Syndrome is purging Moscow’s elite 

Read More
Jackie Allen
3078 Posts

Jackie Allen

Jackie is a freelance journalist and technology geek. She worked as a telecom project director for AT&T and BellSouth. Before joining the USA Herald she has written books, articles, blogs and whitepapers. Her clients include Samsung and other technology companies.

Don’t Miss It
Arizona December 12, 2024
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney Aaron Kelly
By – Paul O'Neal
America March 09, 2026
While the World Watches Iran, Gaza Starves
By – Rochdi Rais
Arizona January 11, 2025
Kelly Warner Law Firm Blames USA Herald for Arizona Bar Investigation

In what appears as a desperate attempt to defend multiple allegations of fraud on the courts, the Kelly Warner Law…

By – USA Herald
Arizona January 4, 2025
Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To Attacking Former Client Again On KellyWarnerLaw.com – Pattern Recognized

Attorney Aaron Kelly and his law partner Daniel Warner are currently under investigation by the Arizona Bar for legal misconduct.…

By – Jeff Watterson
Arizona December 12, 2024
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney Aaron Kelly

USA Herald recently reported on a developing story involving Attorneys Daniel Warner and Aaron Kelly. Both Warner and Kelly have…

By – Paul O'Neal
America March 9, 2026
Pentagon-Anthropic AI Dispute Explodes Into Federal Lawsuits Over AI Safety Policies

A fierce clash at the crossroads of technology, national security, and free speech has erupted in Washington, as the Pentagon-Anthropic…

By – Rachel Moore
America March 9, 2026
G7 Oil Reserve Release Considered as Iran War Disrupts Global Energy Supply

A sudden shock to the world’s oil arteries has pushed major economies toward an emergency response, with a potential G7…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
OpenAI Acquires Promptfoo to Strengthen AI Security and Testing Tools

In a strategic move that underscores the intensifying race to secure advanced artificial intelligence systems, OpenAI acquires Promptfoo, a cybersecurity…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
ISIS New York Attack Charges Filed After Alleged Bomb Plot at NYC Protest

Federal prosecutors have unveiled ISIS New York attack charges against two young men accused of hurling improvised explosive devices during…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7 as Gun Industry Slowdown Claims Another Casualty

The cyclical nature of America’s gun market has once again delivered a hard blow. Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7,…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Iran’s Power Shift: Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei Emerges at the Center of Authority

A quiet but consequential shift inside Iran’s ruling establishment has propelled Mojtaba Khamenei into the role of supreme leader, marking…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Pentagon-Anthropic AI Dispute Explodes Into Federal Lawsuits Over AI Safety Policies

A fierce clash at the crossroads of technology, national security, and free speech has erupted in Washington, as the Pentagon-Anthropic…

By – Rachel Moore
America March 9, 2026
G7 Oil Reserve Release Considered as Iran War Disrupts Global Energy Supply

A sudden shock to the world’s oil arteries has pushed major economies toward an emergency response, with a potential G7…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
OpenAI Acquires Promptfoo to Strengthen AI Security and Testing Tools

In a strategic move that underscores the intensifying race to secure advanced artificial intelligence systems, OpenAI acquires Promptfoo, a cybersecurity…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
ISIS New York Attack Charges Filed After Alleged Bomb Plot at NYC Protest

Federal prosecutors have unveiled ISIS New York attack charges against two young men accused of hurling improvised explosive devices during…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7 as Gun Industry Slowdown Claims Another Casualty

The cyclical nature of America’s gun market has once again delivered a hard blow. Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7,…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Iran’s Power Shift: Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei Emerges at the Center of Authority

A quiet but consequential shift inside Iran’s ruling establishment has propelled Mojtaba Khamenei into the role of supreme leader, marking…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Pentagon-Anthropic AI Dispute Explodes Into Federal Lawsuits Over AI Safety Policies

A fierce clash at the crossroads of technology, national security, and free speech has erupted in Washington, as the Pentagon-Anthropic…

By – Rachel Moore
America March 9, 2026
G7 Oil Reserve Release Considered as Iran War Disrupts Global Energy Supply

A sudden shock to the world’s oil arteries has pushed major economies toward an emergency response, with a potential G7…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
OpenAI Acquires Promptfoo to Strengthen AI Security and Testing Tools

In a strategic move that underscores the intensifying race to secure advanced artificial intelligence systems, OpenAI acquires Promptfoo, a cybersecurity…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
ISIS New York Attack Charges Filed After Alleged Bomb Plot at NYC Protest

Federal prosecutors have unveiled ISIS New York attack charges against two young men accused of hurling improvised explosive devices during…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7 as Gun Industry Slowdown Claims Another Casualty

The cyclical nature of America’s gun market has once again delivered a hard blow. Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7,…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Iran’s Power Shift: Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei Emerges at the Center of Authority

A quiet but consequential shift inside Iran’s ruling establishment has propelled Mojtaba Khamenei into the role of supreme leader, marking…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 8, 2026
The Northern Lights Return

The Northern Lights have a chance to be visible from several northern U.S. states on Tuesday night, forecasters at the…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 8, 2026
February Unemployment Up as Job Losses Surprise Economists

February Unemployment Up as the latest labor market data revealed weaker-than-expected job growth and a slight increase in the national…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 8, 2026
Late-Night Attack by Venezuelan National at Florida Beach

A Late-night attack by a Venezuelan National has left a Florida community shaken after authorities say a 26-year-old man ambushed…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 8, 2026
Trump’s War in Iran: Congress Confronts Escalation After U.S. Strikes

Trump’s War in Iran  was triggered open conflict, casualties, and renewed constitutional debate in Washington. The crisis intensified following reports…

By – Jackie Allen
America February 28, 2026
U.S. And Israel Launch Major Strikes On Iran — What It Means For America

TEHRAN, Iran – In a dramatic escalation of global tensions, the United States and Israel launched coordinated military strikes against Iran…

By – Samuel Lopez
America February 26, 2026
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Overturns $8M Asbestos Verdict Against BNSF Railway Co.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has thrown out an $8 million jury verdict against BNSF Railway…

By – Tyler Brooks
America March 9, 2026
Pentagon-Anthropic AI Dispute Explodes Into Federal Lawsuits Over AI Safety Policies

A fierce clash at the crossroads of technology, national security, and free speech has erupted in Washington, as the Pentagon-Anthropic…

By – Rachel Moore
America March 9, 2026
G7 Oil Reserve Release Considered as Iran War Disrupts Global Energy Supply

A sudden shock to the world’s oil arteries has pushed major economies toward an emergency response, with a potential G7…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
OpenAI Acquires Promptfoo to Strengthen AI Security and Testing Tools

In a strategic move that underscores the intensifying race to secure advanced artificial intelligence systems, OpenAI acquires Promptfoo, a cybersecurity…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
ISIS New York Attack Charges Filed After Alleged Bomb Plot at NYC Protest

Federal prosecutors have unveiled ISIS New York attack charges against two young men accused of hurling improvised explosive devices during…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7 as Gun Industry Slowdown Claims Another Casualty

The cyclical nature of America’s gun market has once again delivered a hard blow. Umbrella Armory filed for Chapter 7,…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America March 9, 2026
Iran’s Power Shift: Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei Emerges at the Center of Authority

A quiet but consequential shift inside Iran’s ruling establishment has propelled Mojtaba Khamenei into the role of supreme leader, marking…

By – Rihem Akkouche
America February 21, 2026
When The Files Are Finally Unsealed The Most Mind-Bending Truth May Not Be What We Expect

[USA HERALD] – There is a widespread assumption that if governments release their most highly classified files related to unidentified…

By – Samuel Lopez
America February 17, 2026
Civil Rights Icon Rev. Jesse Jackson Dies at 84 As President Trump Issues Personal Tribute

[USA HERALD] — The Rev. Jesse Jackson, a towering figure of the American civil rights movement whose career spanned more than…

By – Samuel Lopez
America February 13, 2026
Clues to Savannah Guthrie Missing Mom’s Disappearance Found on Security System

The disappearance of the mother of Savannah Guthrie has taken a dramatic turn as investigators focus on digital clues tied…

By – Jackie Allen
America February 8, 2026
Mike Tyson Urges Americans to ‘Eat Real Food’ in Emotional Super Bowl Ad Highlighting Health Risks

Boxing legend Mike Tyson is using his platform ahead of Super Bowl 60 to address a personal and national health…

By – Tyler Brooks
America February 7, 2026
Deadly “Death Cap” Mushrooms in California Cause Multiple Deaths and Liver Transplants Amid Rare Super Bloom

California health officials are warning the public after four deaths and three liver transplants linked to the highly toxic death…

By – Ahmed Boughalleb
America February 7, 2026
From Migraines to Miracles: How Becca Valle Survived a Glioblastoma Diagnosis Against the Odds

Becca Valle, 41, thought her headaches were just migraines—until a sudden, unbearable pain revealed something far more serious. In September…

By – Tyler Brooks
America March 8, 2026
February Unemployment Up as Job Losses Surprise Economists

February Unemployment Up as the latest labor market data revealed weaker-than-expected job growth and a slight increase in the national…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 8, 2026
Late-Night Attack by Venezuelan National at Florida Beach

A Late-night attack by a Venezuelan National has left a Florida community shaken after authorities say a 26-year-old man ambushed…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 8, 2026
Trump’s War in Iran: Congress Confronts Escalation After U.S. Strikes

Trump’s War in Iran  was triggered open conflict, casualties, and renewed constitutional debate in Washington. The crisis intensified following reports…

By – Jackie Allen
America March 1, 2026
Cadillac Names Inaugural Formula 1 Car MAC-26 in Tribute to Mario Andretti Ahead of 2026 Australian Grand Prix Debut

Cadillac has officially revealed the name of its first Formula 1 challenger, confirming that its 2026 car will be called…

By – Ahmed Boughalleb
America February 20, 2026
Norway Tops Medal Table After Day 13 at 2026 Winter Olympics as Team USA Surges Into Second Place

With 13 days complete at the 2026 Milan Cortina Winter Olympics, Norway sits atop the overall medal standings, collecting 34…

By – Ahmed Boughalleb
America February 18, 2026
Olympic Science Explained: How Figure Skaters Spin at Blinding Speeds Without Getting Dizzy

When Amber Glenn finishes her routine, the arena usually rises with her. The music builds, her blades carve a tight…

By – Tyler Brooks

No posts found.

No posts found.

No comments No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter