In a picturesque landscape where sprawling acres of farmland adorned with rustic charm typically evoke a sense of tranquility, the Foxhollow Farms Nightmare has shattered any illusion of peace. The multi-million-dollar farm in Indiana harbored some dark secrets.
Foxhollow Farms was featured in a documentary and multiple true crime books. Although it has been decades since the murders some secrets remain.
Herb Baumeister, a married father of three and the affluent founder of Sav-A-Lot thrift stores was the owner of Foxhollow Farms.
Hiding behind the veneer of respectability, Baumeister wasn’t who he appeared to be. And his estate was a serial killer’s playground.
His wife would later admit that the couple who were married for 25 years and had only had sex 6 times. She never suspected his secret life.
The family moved to the farmstead in 1988. In 1994 Baumeister’s teenage son discovered a human skull on the property and took it to his mother.
Police, propelled by mounting concerns over Baumeister’s erratic behavior, initiated a search of the estate, unearthing evidence implicating him in the deaths of at least eleven young men.
