FOLLOW US

Wed

June 24, 2026

America February 13, 2025 7 mins read

Sacramento Section-8 Housing Scandal – Landlord Abuse, Tenants at Risk, and SHRA Accountability Under Gov. Code ยง 945.4

America ฤฑ By Samuel Lopez

0 Comments

Untitled

By Samuel A. Lopez, Legal Analyst and Journalist, USA Herald

[SACRAMENTO, CA] - Yesterday, I brought you the story of an unscrupulous Sacramento landlord sentenced to 12 years in prison for egregious abuses, shining a harsh light on the Sacramento Housing & Redevelopment Agency (SHRA) โ€“ Section 8, for what seems like, at minimum, a lack of oversight in the screening and investigating of participating landlords.

And let's not forget, this saga unfolds in Governor Gavin Newsom's home state. As the head of California, Newsom's administration oversees entities like SHRA, which are meant to protect and serve the public, especially in low-income housing matters. Yet, the ongoing issues with SHRA highlight a broader systemic problem within state governance.

If Newsom's vision for California includes safeguarding its citizens from unscrupulous landlords and ensuring accountability from public agencies, then cases like Janis v. Sacramento Housing & Redevelopment Agency should serve as a stark reminder. It's time for his administration to push for reforms, ensuring agencies like SHRA are not just bystanders but active guardians of tenant rights, or else the oversight failures continue to reflect poorly on his leadership.

Today, weโ€™re reporting on the case of: Janis v. Sacramento Housing & Redevelopment Agency.

Imagine you're riding your bike, enjoying a Sacramento afternoon, when suddenly, a car slams into you. You're injured, and it turns out the driver works for SHRA. You think, "I'll sue, get justice." But here's the catch: suing a state entity like SHRA isn't as simple as filing a complaint.

This case serves as a crucial reminder of how an overlooked step in the legal and claims process, can derail an entire case. While the issues at hand stemmed from a bicycle vs car crash, and a clerical error, this case also sheds light on the potential challenges that tenants and other individuals may face when holding public entities accountable.

There's a critical step most peopleโ€”and even some lawyersโ€”miss. Miss it, and your case is dead in the water. That's exactly what happened to Lyle Janis, and I'm here to break it down so you don't make the same mistake.

  • The Hidden Trap of Government Claims: Suing a state entity like SHRA requires filing a written claim first [not a lawsuit]โ€”miss this, and your case is doomed, no matter how strong your evidence.
  • Janis' Misstep Could Be Yours: Janis' lawyer had the evidence but failed to act in time, a mistake that cost him his shot at justice. Learn from this to protect yourself.

Let me paint the picture - September 21, 2021. Lyle Janis is cruising on his bike in Sacramento when Wilfredo Buenafe, driving an SHRA-owned vehicle, allegedly blows through a stop sign and crashes into him. Janis is injuredโ€”pain, medical bills, the works. He hires a lawyer, thinking SHRA should pay for their driver's negligence.

The traffic collision report, delivered to his lawyer's office in December 2021, clearly shows SHRA's involvement. But here's where it goes wrong: his lawyer's secretary fails to calendar the claim deadline, and Janis misses the six-month window to file a claim under California's Government Claims Act (Gov. Code ยง 945.4).

Janis tries to fix it, filing for late claim relief, but the court says no. Why? His lawyer wasn't diligent. She had the report for months but never followed up. The court ruled this wasn't "excusable neglect" under ยง 946.6. Janis' case was dismissed, and SHRA walked away unscathed.

Now, let's connect the dots. Imagine you're renting from a landlord in a SHRA-subsidized property. They're abusive, neglecting repairs, endangering tenant safety, and maybe even one of the landlordsโ€™ resorts to using physical violence against a tenant, causing great bodily injury.

You decide to sue SHRA for failing to oversee them, and for other negligent actions that precipitated the harm or injury caused by the landlord. But, if you don't file a written claim first, your case is toastโ€”just like Janis'. This isn't just legal jargon; it's a lifeline. Knowing this could save you from losing your shot at justice.

Janis' mistake was relying on his lawyer, who dropped the ball. But here's the thing - you can't afford to assume your lawyer knows this obscure rule. If you're suing a state entity, you must file a written claim within six months of the injury (Gov. Code ยง 911.2). Miss it? You can ask for late claim relief, but only if your delay was due to "mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect" (ยง 946.6). Janis' lawyer argued it was a "calendaring mistake," but the court said, "Not good enough. You had the report; you should've acted."

Let's get real - most people don't know this rule exists. Even some lawyers mess it up. If you want to sue SHRA or any state entity for money damages, you must file a written claim first. It's not optional. Under ยง 945.4, you can't file a lawsuit until the claim is presented and either acted on or rejected by the agency. Skip this, and your case is deadโ€”no matter how strong your evidence.

Janis' lawyer launched straight into a lawsuit, but that was the wrong move. She needed to file a claim by March 21, 2022. She missed it, and her late claim application was denied. The court said her neglect wasn't excusable because she had the report for months. This is a wake-up call: if you're in this situation, don't assume your lawyer knows the drill. Ask them, "Have you filed the claim? Are we on time?"

Let's say you miss the six-month window. What now? You can file for late claim relief under ยง 911.4, but you need to show your delay was due to "mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect" (ยง 946.6). If the agency denies your late claim, you can petition the court for relief. But here's the catch: the court will scrutinize your diligence. Janis' lawyer failed because she didn't follow up on the report.

What if you didn't discover the harm until later? The clock starts when you knew or should've known about the injury (ยง 911.2). If you can prove delayed discovery, you might get relief. But you need evidenceโ€”medical records, witness statements, something concrete. Janis didn't have that, and it cost him.

For those of us who might one day find ourselves in Janisโ€™s situation, itโ€™s important to remember that filing claims against the State or State-run entities, is more complicated than it may seem. The process involves not only proving the merits of your case but also adhering to procedural requirements that could ultimately determine whether your case gets heard.

Draft Claim for Janis: A Moot Exercise

This is a basic, bare-bones claim for Janis that complies with ยง945.4. This is moot, but it shows the minimum of what Janis should've or couldโ€™ve done.

Claim Against Sacramento Housing & Redevelopment Agency

Pursuant to Gov. Code ยงยง 910, 945.4

12

Previous Article

Bourbon Street Hustler: Super Bowl Reporterโ€™s Death Linked to Career Criminal

Read More
Samuel Lopez
1616 Posts

Samuel Lopez

With over 20 years of experience in the legal and insurance sectors, Samuel applies his profound legal acumen to investigate and accurately report on the facts.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Donโ€™t Miss It
High Profile Court Cases June 24, 2026
St. Louis County Couple Facing Severe Charges Following Discovery of Years of Child Abuse
By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
High Profile Court Cases June 23, 2026
โ‚ฌ100,000 Reward Offered in Hunt for Barcelona Watch Thief
By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Arizona January 11, 2025
Kelly Warner Law Firm Blames USA…

In what appears as a desperate attempt to defend multiple…

By โ€“ USA Herald
Arizona January 4, 2025
Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To…

Attorney Aaron Kelly and his law partner Daniel Warner are…

By โ€“ Jeff Watterson
Arizona December 12, 2024
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney…

USA Herald recently reported on a developing story involving Attorneys…

By โ€“ Paul O'Neal
High Profile Court Cases June 23, 2026
The Sleight-of-Hand City

How Barcelona became Europeโ€™s pickpocket capital โ€” and the night…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 23, 2026
Was Marilyn Monroe Murdered?

Marilyn Monroe remains one of the most recognizable and influential…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 23, 2026
‘I Have Met Non-Human Intelligence in…

By Samuel Lรณpez | USA Herald They walk among us.…

By โ€“ Samuel Lopez
America June 23, 2026
Biden Cognitive Issues: Court Fight Over…

Questions about Biden cognitive issues surround the former President. This…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
Entertainment June 23, 2026
Kourtney Kardashian Celebrates Travis Barker on…

Kourtney Kardashian had plenty of love to share this Father’s…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Entertainment June 23, 2026
Jay-Z and Roc Nation Win Major…

The legal war between rap mogul Jay-Z and Houston-based attorney…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 23, 2026
Tesla Self-Driving Car Crashes Into Texas…

Federal safety regulators in the United States have launched a…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 23, 2026
NASA Astronaut Heading to Space Station…

For decades, the question of whether life exists beyond Earth…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 22, 2026
Chevron Locks in 20-Year Deal to…

In a landmark partnership that underscores the growing energy demands…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
America June 22, 2026
World Cup History Made as Lionel…

World Cup history was made Monday afternoon in Arlington, Texas,…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 22, 2026
Lucid Motors Slashes 18% of U.S.…

Lucid Group, the luxury electric vehicle maker once seen as…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
America June 22, 2026
Federal Judge Slams Trump DOJ for…

A federal judge has delivered a blistering rebuke to the…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
America June 22, 2026
Final Wish: Oliver Treeโ€™s Family Honors…

Final Wish is how the family of singer Oliver Tree…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 21, 2026
Reflecting Pool Incident Leads to Arrest…

The Reflecting Pool at the Lincoln Memorial has become the…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 21, 2026
Nuclear Talks Begin in Switzerland as…

Nuclear Talks between the United States and Iran officially began…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 20, 2026
Pizza Hut to Be Sold in…

Pizza Hut is entering a new chapter after parent company…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 19, 2026
Jane Street Emerges from the Shadows…

Jane Street is one of the most secretive and profitable…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 19, 2026
Peace Agreement Between US and Iran…

A proposed Peace Agreement framework between the United States and…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 19, 2026
Peace Agreement Between US and Iran…

A proposed Peace Agreement framework between the United States and…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 18, 2026
Internet’s First Serial Killer Used Early…

The story of Serial Killer John Edward Robinson remains one…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 18, 2026
The 9-Second Disaster: The Edge of…

The tech industry is learning that AI autonomy can be…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 17, 2026
Southern Poverty Law Center Indictments Linked…

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), one of the nation’s…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 16, 2026
Anna Kepner Killing: Federal Judge Orders…

The legal proceedings surrounding the cruise ship murder of Anna…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
America June 16, 2026
Russia Shadow Fleet Captain Faces UK…

The captain of a Russian Shadow Fleet tanker intercepted by…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen
Entertainment June 23, 2026
Jay-Z and Roc Nation Win Major…

The legal war between rap mogul Jay-Z and Houston-based attorney…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Entertainment June 22, 2026
GTA 6 Music File Discovered in…

With GTA 6 pre-orders officially opening on Thursday, June 25,…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Business June 22, 2026
Toy Story 5 Shatters Box Office…

When the lights dimmed and the familiar Pixar lamp bounced…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Entertainment June 22, 2026
BTS Comeback Tour Ticket Chaos: Fans…

The long awaited return of global K-pop sensation BTS has…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 20, 2026
Ubisoft Co-Founder Claude Guillemot Dies at…

Claude Guillemot, the co-founder of one of the worldโ€™s largest…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
America June 19, 2026
Anne Hathaway, 43, Stuns Fans with…

In a beautiful and unexpected moment that has sent the…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
Health June 23, 2026
Your Blood Pressure Reading May Be…

Millions of people living with high blood pressure believe that…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 6, 2026
Nichelle Nicholsโ€™ Final Mission Ends in…

By Samuel Lรณpez | USA Herald The woman who helped…

By โ€“ Samuel Lopez
America June 5, 2026
Cannabis Giants Hit with Sweeping Class…

A major class action filed May 4, 2026, accuses five…

By โ€“ Samuel Lopez
Health June 1, 2026
New Pill Doubles Survival for Pancreatic…

Pancreatic cancer pill doubles life to 13 months By Tyler…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
California News May 31, 2026
FDA warns public as cookie firm…

FDA warns public as cookie firm rejects urgent recall request…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Health May 31, 2026
Trump orders CDC to slash childhood…

Trump orders CDC to slash childhood vaccines from 17 to…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
America June 22, 2026
Lionel Messi, at 39, Shatters All-Time…

Lionel Messi has done it again. The Argentine superstar etched…

By โ€“ Rihem Akkouche
Pennsylvania June 22, 2026
Will a Massive Storm Derail the…

The 2026 FIFA World Cup is already delivering unforgettable moments…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Sports June 18, 2026
Extraterrestrial Kickoff? Viral Psychic Warns of…

Football fans around the globe are currently deep in the…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Business June 16, 2026
Dana White Declares The Historic UFC…

WASHINGTON D.C. โ€” It was 3:00 a.m. on Monday, and…

By โ€“ Tyler Brooks
Sports June 15, 2026
Pulisic Is Not Training. What Happens…

Mauricio Pochettino pulled Christian Pulisic at halftime of the USMNT’s…

By โ€“ Nicolas Carreno
America June 14, 2026
New York Chaos Erupts After Knicks…

New York Chaos unfolded across the city after the New…

By โ€“ Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter