FOLLOW US

In a sweeping reversal that echoes like a sudden tide shift, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has asked a Pennsylvania federal court to dramatically scale back its CFPB $5M Biden-Era settlement—a deal that once promised millions in relief for student loan borrowers.

A Settlement Unraveled

The CFPB’s Tuesday filing seeks to unwind much of the relief the agency secured last year against the National Collegiate Student Loan Trusts and their primary servicer, the Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency (PHEAA).

The original settlement, forged in the aftermath of widespread servicing failures before and during the COVID-19 pandemic, required the trusts and PHEAA to pay $2.15 million in fines and distribute nearly $2.9 million to harmed borrowers.

But under the new plan, that redress—once a central pillar of the deal—would be almost entirely erased. Only limited relief for certain service member borrowers would remain. The fines, however, would stay with the government, untouched.

PIMCO’s Challenge Forces a Strategic Retreat

At the heart of the rollback sits investment titan Pacific Investment Management Co. LLC (PIMCO). The firm, which manages funds holding notes in the trusts, appealed the settlement to the Third Circuit, arguing that the terms threatened the contractual rights of noteholders and were agreed to without proper trust authority.

The appellate court steered the dispute into mediation, and what followed was described by all sides as a “fair compromise”—but one with a price: eliminating the settlement’s broad “prospective and injunctive provisions.”

Without those cuts, parties warned, the chance for a final resolution could collapse entirely.

A Calculated CFPB Shift

According to the filings, the CFPB now views the pared-down judgment as aligned with its “current enforcement priorities,” a phrase signaling the agency’s broader pivot under new leadership.

Since February, the administration has dismantled much of the CFPB’s prior enforcement portfolio and slashed its resources. The agency has even warned that it may soon be unable to continue normal operations as funding dwindles.

Against that backdrop, the rollback appears not only strategic—but necessary.

A Narrow Path to Closure

The parties urged the court to modify the judgments under Rule 60(b)(5), arguing that the injunctive terms “are now the sole impediment to a complete resolution of this case.”

Should the court approve the revisions, all litigation—including PIMCO’s appeal—would dissolve.

Attorneys for the CFPB, PHEAA, PIMCO, and the loan trusts did not immediately respond to requests for comment Wednesday.