FOLLOW US

As if the turbulent seas had momentarily stilled, the contention surrounding offshore wind energy development along New York and New Jersey's coasts experienced a sudden lull. This came as an advocacy group decided to hoist the white flag, at least for the time being.

A Twist in the Windy Tale

"Save Long Beach Island," along with its president Robert Stern, decided to drop anchor and retract its sails against the might of the Biden administration's wind energy push. Their decision to voluntarily abandon their suit, filed just at the dawn of 2022, came as a sudden gust after federal agencies declared the group's amended complaint as "floating in the wrong waters" due to jurisdictional concerns.

The crux of the dispute? A March 2021 memorandum from the BOEM, which earmarked five wind energy zones, painting a picture of turbines rising from New Jersey's Cape May, reaching out to the eastern edge of Long Island, NY, in the stretch named the New York Bight. The group's initial outcry against the move came just before the region attracted a storm of $4.4 billion in bids for wind energy development rights.

Legal Squalls and Calm Seas

By March 2022, BOEM countered with a wave of its own, questioning the court's authority to even entertain the suit. They argued that their memo was merely the whisper of the wind, an initial step with negligible real-world impacts. This left the advocacy group's concerns over endangered species and environmental policies seemingly adrift without a rudder. U.S. District Judge Dabney L. Friedrich found weight in this argument, declaring the complaint as unripe and pushing it off the legal deck in March 2023.

BOEM, still charting its course, signaled its intentions in July 2022 for a thorough environmental impact analysis, even as they reported receiving site plans without any solid construction blueprints for the New York Bight as of late September.

Rallying its forces, "Save Long Beach Island" sought to expand its challenge, encompassing the entirety of Atlantic Coast's offshore wind endeavors. The federal government, however, found the new sails to be cut from the same cloth, bearing the same flaws as the initial complaint.

The Breeze Before the Storm?

Despite the advocacy group's retreat this Tuesday, the waters remain murky. The group's ambitions to compel BOEM for broader environmental scrutiny and project examinations, the government argues, aren't grounded in the Administrative Procedure Act.

While the immediate tussle has calmed, with the representatives from both sides maintaining radio silence, one can't help but wonder if this is just the calm before another storm in the New York Bight offshore wind saga.