Insurance Giants Fail to Escape Pollution Coverage Suit Involving Bad Faith Claims

148
SHARE

According to the initial complaint, CCMA states that sometime in 2000 it hired LAN Associated Inc., an environmental services company, to assist it in coming up with a remedial plan to mitigate losses against certain environmental risks that were present at its facility in Calvert City, Kentucky.

Once the plan was created, CCMA then sought coverage under its AIG policy to fund the remedial cleanup efforts in 2003, a policy that CCMA said extended coverage for certain types of cleanup costs until December 2023.

In the complaint, CCMA said that for 18 years, it was routinely reimbursed by its insurer for “all submitted costs incurred by CCMA to implement the remedial plan.” However, CCMA says that in October 2020, AIG changed its coverage position and began to deny coverage for “operations, maintenance, and monitoring costs.”

AIG and Fortitude Reinsurance Company Ltd. filed a motion to dismiss the case but the court was not persuaded by the arguments, as such their request was denied.

On Monday, U.S. District Judge Claria Horn Boom went further to reject the insurers’ attempt to avoid CCMA’s claims related to future cleanup costs, because as judge Boom stated, these claims were not “purely hypothetical.”