FOLLOW US

Spin Master Ltd., a prominent toy manufacturer based in Ontario, is embroiled in a contentious legal battle over royalties, according to a lawsuit filed in Suffolk Superior Court. The complaint accuses Spin Master of underpaying Massachusetts-based BBX Design Group for designs linked to its popular remote-controlled monster trucks.

Spin Master Royalties Lawsuit:  Dispute Over Royalty Payments

BBX Design Group's lawsuit, filed on Friday, claims Spin Master has refused to pay royalties for several products, arguing that these items fall outside the scope of a 2018 licensing agreement. This deal covered the "Moon Shot" toy design, characterized by a remote-controlled vehicle with oversized foam wheels. The dispute centers on Spin Master's assertion that the royalties for seven products are invalid due to the "softness" of the wheels, which it argues diverges from the agreement’s terms.

Contractual Conflict and Claims

BBX argues that the license agreement only specifies "large foam wheels," without detailing the texture or firmness. The company's lawsuit accuses Spin Master of acting in bad faith by claiming that its products' "soft foam wheels" are not covered by the agreement. BBX alleges this stance is a deliberate attempt to evade paying owed royalties.

The lawsuit includes accusations of breach of contract, breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, unjust enrichment, promissory estoppel, and violation of Massachusetts' unfair trade practices statute.

Spin Master Royalties Lawsuit:  Products in Dispute

The lawsuit highlights that the contested products include Monster Jam remote-controlled vehicles, such as replicas of Grave Digger, Megalodon, and El Toro Loco trucks. Additionally, royalties are claimed for Spin Master's all-terrain Batmobile toy.

BBX claims that Spin Master never indicated that toys with "soft, squishy" wheels were excluded from the licensing agreement. The design firm also accuses Spin Master of retaliation by deducting patent costs related to the licensed items without proper notification, as required by the agreement.

Legal Representation

BBX Design Group is represented by Mitchell J. Matorin of Matorin Law Office LLC. As of now, representatives for Spin Master have not responded to requests for comment, and their legal counsel’s information is unavailable.

The legal battle underscores the complexities and high stakes involved in licensing agreements within the toy industry.