FOLLOW US

America February 27, 2025 5 mins read

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Alito Blasts 9th Circuit in San Jose Police Shooting Case

America ı By Samuel Lopez

0 Comments

Untitled

By Samuel A. Lopez – USA Herald

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals just got an earful from U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, who harshly criticized its handling of a police shooting case in San Jose. The case involves the 2017 fatal shooting of Jacob Dominguez, an unarmed man, by San Jose Police Sgt. Michael Pina. A federal jury found the officer had used excessive force, awarding Dominguez's widow and children $1 million in damages.

Alito, however, is having none of it, calling the lower courts' decisions "a flagrant error" and lambasting the appellate judges for what he described as "ham-fisted" reasoning. The justice argued that the courts "ran roughshod" over the doctrine of qualified immunity and based their decision on a 2022 case that was decided years after the shooting. But is Alito's outrage justified, or is this just another example of the Supreme Court's conservative wing trying to protect law enforcement at all costs?

The core of the dispute lies in the legal principle of qualified immunity — a doctrine designed to shield government officials, including police officers, from civil lawsuits unless they violate "clearly established" legal precedents. But what does "clearly established" even mean? That’s the million-dollar question (or, in this case, the $1 million question).

When Dominguez was shot in 2017, Pina and his legal team claimed he was protected under qualified immunity. However, U.S. District Judge Beth Labson Freeman disagreed. She ruled that Pina could be held accountable, partially relying on the 9th Circuit's ruling in Peck v. Montoya — a 2022 case where deputies fatally shot a blind man.

Here’s where things get murky: Peck was decided five years after Dominguez’s death. Alito pounced on this point, arguing that the lower courts “badly fumbled” by using a decision that wasn’t in place at the time of the shooting. But Judge Freeman had an answer for that. She pointed out that Peck built on an even older case, Cruz v. City of Anaheim, which had already set a precedent on excessive force in traffic stops. In other words, Peck wasn’t rewriting the rules — it was reinforcing them.

Published vs. Unpublished Decisions: Does It Matter?

Another legal wrinkle here is that the 9th Circuit’s decision in the Dominguez case was unpublished — meaning it wasn’t intended to set a binding precedent. Alito suggested this made the ruling even weaker, but legal experts disagree.

Unpublished decisions don’t carry the same weight as published ones, but they do influence similar cases, especially when they align with existing law. The appellate panel explicitly stated that “a reasonable jury could have found that Dominguez did not appear to be reaching for a weapon when Officer Pina shot him.” And under established precedent, that means deadly force wasn’t justified.

Alito’s View: Protecting Officers or Undermining Accountability?

Justice Alito’s dissent is essentially a full-throated defense of qualified immunity. His concern? That police officers shouldn’t have to worry about lawsuits when making split-second decisions.

“To overcome qualified immunity, a party must show that an official violated a federal right that was ‘clearly established’ at the time of the alleged misconduct,” Alito wrote.

In other words, Pina could not have known that killing Dominguez would expose him to a civil lawsuit because, according to Alito, the law wasn’t "clear enough" at the time.

Legal scholars like UCLA Law Professor Joanna C. Schwartz argue that this reasoning is flawed. “The notion that you have to find a prior court decision with nearly identical facts in order to clearly establish the law can be a very high barrier,” Schwartz said.

Even if Peck had been decided before the shooting, it’s unlikely Pina would have been aware of it in the heat of the moment. Officers don’t memorize legal precedents; they’re trained on general principles of law. That’s why courts have to interpret whether force was justified after the fact.

The Bigger Picture: Qualified Immunity and Its Impact

This case is yet another example of the deep flaws in the qualified immunity doctrine. While the Supreme Court insists the rule is needed to prevent frivolous lawsuits against officers, research suggests it does little to achieve that goal. Schwartz’s studies indicate that most excessive force claims are not dismissed on qualified immunity grounds.

And here’s a reality check: even when officers are found liable, they rarely pay out of pocket. Studies show that police departments and cities almost always foot the bill. So, the idea that officers are constantly at risk of personal financial ruin? It’s a myth.

The bigger danger isn’t to officers — it’s to communities. When qualified immunity is applied too broadly, it shields bad cops just as much as good ones. And in cases like Dominguez’s, it prevents families from getting justice.

As for Alito’s outrage? It’s misplaced. The courts ruled in favor of Dominguez’s widow because they were right to do so. And if you ask Dominguez’s children, they’d probably tell you that $1 million isn’t nearly enough.

  • Court Decisions & Case Law:
    • Peck v. Montoya(2022) - [Link]
    • Cruz v. City of Anaheim(2014) - [Link]
    • Qualified Immunity Overview - [Link]
  • Legal Analysis: For a deeper dive into legal analysis without the jargon, join my Patreon community, Legal Insights and Strategies by Samuel Lopez, for exclusive content, templates, and insider tips.

Previous Article

Space Geeks: AstroForge Aims to Make History

Read More
2048 Posts

Samuel Lopez

With over 20 years of experience in the legal and insurance sectors, Samuel applies his profound legal acumen to investigate and accurately report on the facts.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion!

Don’t Miss It
America November 19, 2026 Walmart raises its outlook for the year for the 3rd time By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026 Bed bugs force FEMA staff to work from home By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026 Anthropic shares jump 21% after $107.3B IPO By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026 Binance Wins $6.5B Freezing Order Over Hack By – Rachel Moore
America November 19, 2026
43 Soldiers Unlock a GTA 6…

FORT STEWART, Ga. — The 9th Brigade Engineer Battalion offered…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 19, 2026
Lawmakers Press Lutnick Family Over Nvidia…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 19, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 19, 2026
Palmer Luckey Warns AI Hackers Are…

NEW YORK — Palmer Luckey says artificial intelligence is giving…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 19, 2026
Iowa Schools Cancel Classes as Army…

MIDDLETOWN, Iowa — Schools in southeast Iowa have canceled Friday…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 19, 2026
“A Nuclear War Cannot Be Won”:…

SHENZHEN, China — For the first time in history, the…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 19, 2026
“Looking at Gases, Looking at Bio”:…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The simmering war with Iran flared on…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 18, 2026
Government Investigators Find AI Platforms Generated…

Federal investigators found that four major artificial intelligence platforms could…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 18, 2026
Yellowstone’ Star Luke Grimes Opens Up…

Key Takeaways Luke Grimes admits he was worried about continuing…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 18, 2026
Florida Flood Threat: Record Downpours Swamp…

The Florida flood threat turned real overnight. Torrential rainfall and…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 18, 2026
Anthropic BIPA Suit: Illinois User Says…

The Anthropic BIPA suit alleges that a routine identity check…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 18, 2026
Oregon Accuses ChatGPT Maker of Endangering…

The OpenAI $2B lawsuit has put one of the world’s…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 18, 2026
Is GTA 6 Out? Rockstar’s Blockbuster…

Is GTA 6 out? The answer depends on where you…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 18, 2026
Iran Says It Targeted Kuwaiti Air…

Iran’s military said it targeted Ali Al Salem Air Base…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
China to Lift 25% Tariff on…

SHENZHEN, China — Canadian pork processors lost roughly a quarter…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
WSJ Reports Nvidia SEC Probe After…

WASHINGTON — Before Jensen Huang resigned, Nvidia described his interactions…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
Brazil Probes Whether Vance-Linked Group Aided…

Brazilian federal police are investigating whether Rockbridge Network, a U.S.…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 18, 2026
13 U.S. Babies Born With Measles…

U.S. officials documented 13 babies born with measles and 112…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 17, 2026
Katie Couric Reveals  Memory-Loss Episode That…

Katie Couric is opening up about a recent frightening medical…

By – Jackie Allen
Breaking News November 19, 2026
Anthropic Hits the Nasdaq Today as…

NEW YORK — Wall Street’s biggest initial public offering ever…

By – Derek Johnson
Business November 18, 2026
GTA VI Is Finally Here: Rockstar’s…

NEW YORK — After a 13-year wait, the most anticipated…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 17, 2026
Kiefer Sutherland Seeks Dismissal and Claims…

LOS ANGELES — Kiefer Sutherland, best known for portraying counterterrorism…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 17, 2026
Russell Brand Wife Publishes His Defiant…

LONDON — Russell Brand is facing an investigation by British…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 17, 2026
eBay $55.7M Mass. Couple Settlement: Insurer…

The eBay $55.7M Mass. couple settlement has now landed in…

By – Rachel Moore
America November 17, 2026
NSA Classified Internal Network Goes Offline

WASHINGTON — The NSA’s classified internal network, used to store…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 15, 2026
Hackers Hit America’s Drinking Water Systems…

ATLANTA – Hackers have crossed a dangerous line in America’s…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 15, 2026
America Loses Its Measles-Free Status for…

WASHINGTON, D.C. — For the first time in a quarter…

By – Derek Johnson
America November 11, 2026
Brooklyn Building Collapse Kills 2 as…

A Brooklyn building collapse killed at least two people and…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
A Veterans Day Betrayal: House Advances…

OPINION | The Republican-led House marked Veterans Day by advancing…

By – Michallie K Harrison
America November 11, 2026
AI Godfather Warns of Chernobyl-Style Blackout…

By Samuel LĂłpez | USA Herald | November 11, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 10, 2026
Vitamin K Deficiency Bleeding: Why the…

A single injection administered in the first hours of life…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 15, 2026
Tower Hill Investment in Gator Athletics:…

The Tower Hill investment in Gator Athletics just rewrote the…

By – Tyler Brooks
America November 14, 2026
Golden State Valkyries Star Gabby Williams…

 Golden State Valkyries forward Gabby Williams believes Indiana Fever star…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 8, 2026
Dana White Reportedly Declines Trump White…

By Samuel Lopez – USA Herald | November 8, 2026…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 7, 2026
Mike Tyson And Ric Flair Score…

Inside the $50 Million Legal Battle A federal judge rejected…

By – Samuel Lopez
America November 5, 2026
Dallas Cowboys Face  Crisis After Crushing…

By Jackie Allen | USA Herald The Dallas Cowboys are…

By – Jackie Allen
America November 4, 2026
WNBA: DeWanna Bonner Makes Emotional Admission…

ATLANTA — The WNBA Finals ended in heartbreak for the…

By – Jackie Allen

No posts found.

No posts found.

Signup for the USA Herald
exclusive Newsletter