Judge Montgomery-Reeves penned, “Appellants do not plausibly allege, however, that Polsinelli breached its specific executory promise to ‘provide legal counsel.’”
In a final note, while Philidor tried playing the unjust enrichment card as a Plan B, hoping to show the contract as unenforceable, the Third Circuit deemed the pharmacy’s case references as irrelevant.
Silence followed the thrilling resolution as counsels from both sides refrained from commenting on Wednesday’s verdict.
The Third Circuit panel included U.S. Circuit Judges Michael A. Chagares, Thomas M. Hardiman, and Tamika R. Montgomery-Reeves. Philidor and Davenport’s legal shield comprised Ralph P. Ferrara, Kevin J. Kotch, and Aaron L. Peskin from the Ferrara Law Group, while Polsinelli PC had the trio of Robert M. Cary, James W. Kirkpatrick III, and Craig Singer from Williams & Connolly.
