Apache Tribe Claims 9th Circuit Ruling Strips Away Religious Protections
America ı By USA Herald
143 0 Comments
3 Quick Takeaways:
- Religious Rights at Risk: The San Carlos Apache Tribe claims a recent Ninth Circuit ruling undermines protections for sacred religious sites, posing an existential threat to Native American communities.
- Sacred Ground for Copper: A copper mining project by Resolution Copper stands to take over Oak Flat, a spiritual site as vital to the Apaches as Mount Sinai is to many religious groups.
- Supreme Court's Role Looms: The tribe urges the U.S. Supreme Court to reverse the decision, which they argue violates the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and sets a dangerous precedent for all faiths
Copper vs. Sacred Land: Apaches Fight to Save Oak Flat in Landmark Religious Rights Case
[USA Herald - September 14, 2024] - The San Carlos Apache Tribe is in a race against time to protect Oak Flat, their holiest site, from being turned into a sprawling copper mine. Following a deeply divisive ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court, the tribe now looks to the U.S. Supreme Court to halt the federal government’s planned land swap with Resolution Copper, a joint venture between mining giants Rio Tinto and BHP. The decision, which has broader implications for religious freedom across the country, could reshape the future of sacred site protections for Native Americans and beyond.
In a legal battle that links religion, land rights, and corporate power, the Apaches of Arizona’s San Carlos Reservation are fighting to save their sacred site, Oak Flat. Situated in the Tonto National Forest, Oak Flat has been a spiritual and cultural hub for generations of Apache people. The site is now under threat from a land transfer deal that would give 2,500 acres of tribal land to Resolution Copper in exchange for nearby federal land—potentially paving the way for one of the largest copper mines in North America.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled earlier this year in a split decision that the land swap did not violate the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), effectively allowing the federal government to bypass significant protections for Native religious sites. The court’s decision has been a lightning rod for criticism, not only from Native American communities but from religious freedom advocates across the country.
"If the federal government can destroy a sacred Native American site without thorough RFRA review, what's stopping them from doing the same to other places of worship—whether it's a cathedral or a mosque?" Samuel Lopez.
The tribe’s petition to the U.S. Supreme Court argues that the Ninth Circuit’s ruling is not only a violation of religious rights but also an existential threat to Native cultures. "Oak Flat is our Mt. Sinai—the most sacred place where generations of Apache have come to connect with our Creator, our faith, and our land," said Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr., a prominent leader in the fight to save Oak Flat.
Despite these heartfelt pleas, the Ninth Circuit's en banc decision has set a precedent that has far-reaching consequences beyond Native American communities. The Apache Stronghold, the nonprofit group leading the legal fight, emphasizes that the ruling could extend to religious exercises on federal lands across the country. For example, the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal organization, were recently barred from holding their traditional mass at Poplar Grove National Cemetery in Virginia, marking a disturbing new chapter in religious freedom law.
This conflict pits the federal government’s land use policies against centuries-old Native American religious traditions. Advocates for the tribe argue that the Ninth Circuit's ruling grants the government unchecked authority to repurpose sacred land for commercial use, jeopardizing the religious rights of minority groups in particular.
The broader legal landscape surrounding the Religious Freedom Restoration Act is also at stake. Passed in 1993, RFRA was designed to prevent the government from imposing undue burdens on religious practices. However, the Ninth Circuit’s interpretation appears to give the government significant leeway to override RFRA protections when it comes to federal land, where most Native American sacred sites are located.
The case now heads to the Supreme Court, which has the potential to either uphold the Ninth Circuit’s ruling or reaffirm RFRA's application to Native American religious sites. Religious freedom groups from all corners of the nation are watching the case closely, as a ruling against the Apaches could endanger religious practices on federal land far beyond Arizona.
Apache Stronghold is represented by Luke W. Goodrich, Diana Verm Thompson, and others from the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, along with Erin E. Murphy of Clement & Murphy PLLC, Stephanie Hall Barclay of Georgetown Law, and Michael V. Nixon of Clifford Levenson.
The U.S. government’s legal team includes Todd Kim, Katelin Shugart-Schmidt, and Joan M. Pepin from the DOJ’s Environment and Natural Resources Division.
Resolution Copper is represented by Michael R. Huston, Christopher D. Thomas, and others from Perkins Coie LLP.
The case is Apache Stronghold v. U.S. et al., case number 24A110, in the U.S. Supreme Court.
FOLLOW US
Recent Posts
Kelly Warner Law Firm Blames USA Herald for Arizona Bar…
Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To Attacking Former Client Again…
Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney Aaron Kelly
Thomas Medlin Found Dead in Brooklyn Waters After Two-Month Search
American Refuelling Aircraft Crashed in Iraq During Military Operation
Astronomers Witness Birth of a Magnetar in Explosive Cosmic Event
Firefly Launches Alpha Flight 7 Mission Successfully from California Spaceport
Microsoft Copilot Health AI Tool Launches to Help Users Understand…
FTC Refunds for Invitation Homes: $47.2 Million Headed to Hundreds…
Palantir and Nvidia Partnership Unveiled as AI Alliances Expand at…
Don’t Miss It
Old Dominion University Shooting Investigated as Terrorism After Gunman Identified
By – Rihem AkkoucheGulf Travelers’ Jet Prices Soar as War Disrupts Middle East Air Travel
By – Rihem AkkoucheShooting at Michigan Synagogue Leaves Suspect Dead After Security Confrontation
By – Rihem AkkoucheStolen Military Drones And The Emerging Threat of Foreign UAV Attacks On The California Coast
By – Samuel LopezHollywood’s “Disclosure Day” And Washington’s Silence Raise Questions About Timing of UFO Transparency
By – Samuel LopezThe World Cup Security Reckoning: Trump Warns Iran Soccer Team About Safety As War Tensions Spill Into Global Sports
By – Samuel LopezScientists Identify 22 Anomalies In Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS As It Leaves The Solar System
By – Samuel LopezIran Appears To Have Conducted Its First Major Cyberattack Against A U.S. Company, Since The War Began – New Front Opens Against American Healthcare
By – Samuel Lopez
Hormuz Shock Hits U.S. Legal And Insurance Sectors As War Risk, Cargo Claims And Contract Fights Begin to Spread
By Samuel A. Lopez | USA Herald – The developing Strait of Hormuz crisis is no longer just an energy-market…
By – Samuel Lopez
Beyond Gas Prices The Strait of Hormuz Crisis Could Hit Fertilizer, Plastics, Aluminum And Global Supply Chains
By Samuel Lopez | USA Herald – Right now, most Americans hearing about the Strait of Hormuz are thinking about…
By – Samuel Lopez
Fani Willis Blocked From Trump Fee Fight As Georgia Judge Lets $16.8 Million Reimbursement Battle Move Forward
INSIDE THIS REPORT A Georgia judge has ruled that Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis cannot re-enter the collapsed Trump…
By – Samuel Lopez
FBI Bulletin Raises Troubling Questions About California’s Readiness
[USA HERALD] – A leaked FBI bulletin has now forced an uncomfortable question into the open along California’s coast. If…
By – Samuel Lopez
Cumulus Media Files for Chapter 11 as Radio Giant Moves to Cut Massive Debt
In a dramatic turn for one of America’s largest radio broadcasters, Cumulus Media has filed for bankruptcy protection, seeking a…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Gordie Howe Bridge Tolls Revealed Ahead of Spring Opening
The long-awaited Gordie Howe International Bridge is inching closer to welcoming travelers, and officials have finally unveiled a key piece…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Gordie Howe Bridge Tolls Revealed Ahead of Spring Opening
The long-awaited Gordie Howe International Bridge is inching closer to welcoming travelers, and officials have finally unveiled a key piece…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Nasa Satellite to Crash to Earth as Spacecraft Re-enters Atmosphere
A Nasa satellite to crash to Earth has prompted warnings from space officials, who say debris from the aging spacecraft…
By – Rachel Moore
Lux Aeterna $10M Seed Funding Fuels Ambitious Reusable Satellite Vision
A Colorado startup aiming to change how satellites operate — and survive — in space has secured fresh investment to…
By – Rachel Moore
Jupiter’s Shift Direction Lights Up the Night Sky Again
Skywatchers may notice something unusual unfolding overhead this week as Jupiter’s shift direction brings an end to months of celestial…
By – Rachel Moore
Google and Tesla Power Grid Initiative Targets Lower Energy Costs
Two of the world’s most influential technology companies are stepping into the energy policy arena, launching a campaign they say…
By – Rachel Moore
Medtronic to Buy Scientia Vascular in $550 Million Neurovascular Deal
In a move poised to reshape the future of stroke treatment technology, Medtronic to buy Scientia Vascular marks a major…
By – Rachel Moore
Medtronic to Buy Scientia Vascular in $550 Million Neurovascular Deal
In a move poised to reshape the future of stroke treatment technology, Medtronic to buy Scientia Vascular marks a major…
By – Rachel Moore
Winklevoss Twins’ Bitcoin Transfer Sparks Market Speculation
A wave of cryptocurrency movement tied to the founders of the Gemini exchange is drawing fresh attention across the digital…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Alabama Man Fatal Shooting Death Sentence Commuted by Governor
In a rare act of clemency that halted an imminent execution, the Alabama man fatal shooting death sentence tied to…
By – Rihem Akkouche
US Consulate Shooting in Toronto Triggers National Security Investigation
Authorities in Canada are investigating the US consulate shooting in Toronto after gunfire struck the diplomatic building early Monday morning…
By – Rihem Akkouche
ExxonMobil to Move to Texas in Historic Corporate Shift
In a move that could reshape the corporate map of one of America’s most powerful energy companies, ExxonMobil to move…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Rhoda AI Secures $450M Funding to Power Next-Gen Industrial Robots
In a move set to electrify the robotics industry, Rhoda AI $450M funding marks one of the largest early-stage investments…
By – Rihem Akkouche
Trump’s Laser Talk Sparks New Questions About America’s Secret Arsenal
President Donald Trump has once again done what he often does best in moments of war and tension: he dropped…
By – Samuel Lopez
The Northern Lights Return
The Northern Lights have a chance to be visible from several northern U.S. states on Tuesday night, forecasters at the…
By – Jackie Allen
February Unemployment Up as Job Losses Surprise Economists
February Unemployment Up as the latest labor market data revealed weaker-than-expected job growth and a slight increase in the national…
By – Jackie Allen
Late-Night Attack by Venezuelan National at Florida Beach
A Late-night attack by a Venezuelan National has left a Florida community shaken after authorities say a 26-year-old man ambushed…
By – Jackie Allen
Trump’s War in Iran: Congress Confronts Escalation After U.S. Strikes
Trump’s War in Iran was triggered open conflict, casualties, and renewed constitutional debate in Washington. The crisis intensified following reports…
By – Jackie Allen
U.S. And Israel Launch Major Strikes On Iran — What It Means For America
TEHRAN, Iran – In a dramatic escalation of global tensions, the United States and Israel launched coordinated military strikes against Iran…
By – Samuel Lopez
Rhoda AI Secures $450M Funding to Power Next-Gen Industrial Robots
In a move set to electrify the robotics industry, Rhoda AI $450M funding marks one of the largest early-stage investments…
By – Rihem Akkouche
3I/ATLAS Shocks Astronomers With Fuel-Like Methanol Molecule At Extraordinary Levels
[USA HERALD] – There are ordinary space stories, and then there are the stories that make even seasoned observers stop…
By – Samuel Lopez
War Abroad, Risk At Home: Why Americans Are Quietly Reviewing Insurance Policies As Global Conflicts Expand
[USA HERALD] – As the United States confronts rising geopolitical tensions and the possibility of military engagement on multiple fronts…
By – Samuel Lopez
Pentagon-Anthropic AI Dispute Explodes Into Federal Lawsuits Over AI Safety Policies
A fierce clash at the crossroads of technology, national security, and free speech has erupted in Washington, as the Pentagon-Anthropic…
By – Rachel Moore
G7 Oil Reserve Release Considered as Iran War Disrupts Global Energy Supply
A sudden shock to the world’s oil arteries has pushed major economies toward an emergency response, with a potential G7…
By – Rihem Akkouche
OpenAI Acquires Promptfoo to Strengthen AI Security and Testing Tools
In a strategic move that underscores the intensifying race to secure advanced artificial intelligence systems, OpenAI acquires Promptfoo, a cybersecurity…
By – Rihem Akkouche
When The Files Are Finally Unsealed The Most Mind-Bending Truth May Not Be What We Expect
[USA HERALD] – There is a widespread assumption that if governments release their most highly classified files related to unidentified…
By – Samuel Lopez
Civil Rights Icon Rev. Jesse Jackson Dies at 84 As President Trump Issues Personal Tribute
[USA HERALD] — The Rev. Jesse Jackson, a towering figure of the American civil rights movement whose career spanned more than…
By – Samuel Lopez
Clues to Savannah Guthrie Missing Mom’s Disappearance Found on Security System
The disappearance of the mother of Savannah Guthrie has taken a dramatic turn as investigators focus on digital clues tied…
By – Jackie Allen
Mike Tyson Urges Americans to ‘Eat Real Food’ in Emotional Super Bowl Ad Highlighting Health Risks
Boxing legend Mike Tyson is using his platform ahead of Super Bowl 60 to address a personal and national health…
By – Tyler Brooks
Deadly “Death Cap” Mushrooms in California Cause Multiple Deaths and Liver Transplants Amid Rare Super Bloom
California health officials are warning the public after four deaths and three liver transplants linked to the highly toxic death…
By – Ahmed Boughalleb
From Migraines to Miracles: How Becca Valle Survived a Glioblastoma Diagnosis Against the Odds
Becca Valle, 41, thought her headaches were just migraines—until a sudden, unbearable pain revealed something far more serious. In September…
By – Tyler Brooks
Cadillac Names Inaugural Formula 1 Car MAC-26 in Tribute to Mario Andretti Ahead of 2026 Australian Grand Prix Debut
Cadillac has officially revealed the name of its first Formula 1 challenger, confirming that its 2026 car will be called…
By – Ahmed Boughalleb
Norway Tops Medal Table After Day 13 at 2026 Winter Olympics as Team USA Surges Into Second Place
With 13 days complete at the 2026 Milan Cortina Winter Olympics, Norway sits atop the overall medal standings, collecting 34…
By – Ahmed Boughalleb
Olympic Science Explained: How Figure Skaters Spin at Blinding Speeds Without Getting Dizzy
When Amber Glenn finishes her routine, the arena usually rises with her. The music builds, her blades carve a tight…
By – Tyler Brooks
Olympic Villages Run Out of Condoms at 2026 Milan-Cortina Games
Condom supplies in the Olympic Villages at the 2026 Winter Games have been temporarily depleted, the Milan-Cortina organizing committee confirmed,…
By – Tyler Brooks
Arizona Authorities Escalate Search for Savannah Guthrie’s Mom to a Criminal Investigation
In Arizona, police are intensifying their investigation into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie’s Mom. The 84-year-old mother of…
By – Jackie AllenAs conversations around sexuality continue to expand, so does the language we use to describe it. Sexuality terms are gaining…
By – Jackie AllenNo posts found.
No posts found.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!