Court Proceedings and Timeline
The case suffered an initial setback for Samantha when it was dismissed by a lower court in March 2024. However, the legal system’s appellate process has provided her with an opportunity to challenge that dismissal. The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals initially set a tentative hearing date for the week beginning August 11, but recent court filings confirm the oral arguments have been rescheduled for Tuesday, September 9, 2025, at 9 a.m. local time in Jacksonville, Florida.
This appellate hearing represents a critical juncture in the legal proceedings. Unlike a trial on the merits, these oral arguments will focus on whether the lower court correctly applied the law when dismissing Samantha’s original complaint. The appellate court will examine legal precedents, constitutional protections, and the specific allegations to determine whether the case should proceed to trial.
The Broader Context of Royal Family Relations
The lawsuit emerges from a complex web of family relationships that became increasingly strained following Meghan’s marriage to Prince Harry in 2018. Thomas Markle Sr., Meghan’s father, has been estranged from his daughter since before her royal wedding, creating a rift that has extended to other family members, including Samantha.
Samantha Markle has been particularly vocal in media appearances, frequently commenting on her half-sister’s public statements and royal role. This pattern of public commentary has created a backdrop of tension that culminated in the formal legal challenge.
