FOLLOW US

(USA Herald) - As a policyholder, you expect your insurance company to have your best interests in mind. Unfortunately, some insurance companies put profits before their clients, leading to bad faith conduct. In cases of bad faith, policyholders can hold their insurer accountable in court. The following seven real-life examples of high bad faith insurance settlement amounts show the impact of insurer misconduct.

1. Matson Terminals v. Home Insurance Co. – settlement: $33.65 million

The Home Insurance Company denied coverage for a $10 million earthquake claim, leading to a lawsuit. A California jury found the refusal to provide support based on a policy exclusion was in bad faith. The jury awarded $11 million in punitive damages, and an appeals court affirmed the award, including $23.5 million in compensatory damages. The appeals court also held that the insurer led the policyholder under the false pretense of coverage, exacerbating the bad faith.

2. Vann v. The Travelers Insurance Company – award: $26.5 million

Mr. Vann, a former owner of an auto repair shop, requested his insurer to provide a defense after being sued for environmental damage caused to the property. The Travelers Insurance Company initially denied a policy existed, and once found, requested impossible personal information from Vann. A jury found The Travelers Insurance Company guilty of bad faith, leading to an award of $26.5 million upheld by the Supreme Court.

3. Pinto v. Farmers Ins. Exchange – award: $10 million

A California Appeals Court found a bad faith failure to settle the claim in this case. Pinto was a passenger injured in a solo vehicle accident, leaving him paralyzed. Farmers conducted an inadequate investigation of the claim, and failed to provide Pinto with critical information. The insurer appealed, and the $10 million judgment against them was reversed due to inadequate jury verdicts.

4. David Clayton v. United Services Automobile Association – award: $3.9 million

The insurance company, US Automobile Association, offered $10,000 on policy limits of $300,000 for a case where the only child of two parents was killed in an auto accident. The jury felt this was inadequate and in bad faith, leading to an award of $3.9 million.

5. Boicourt v. Amex Assurance Co. – award: $2,006,000

The insurance carrier, Amex Assurance Company, initially refused in bad faith to disclose policy limits after a vehicle accident severely injured a young boy. The initial settlement of $2 million was pursuant to a policy that provided only $100,000 in coverage.