The two retired Pittsburg Steelers players asserted, “The NFL’s scheme – executed through the League-sponsored Settlement Agreement – is particularly insidious because it presumes Black retirees to be less intelligent than their non-Black fellow retirees.”
“The NFL’s enforcement of the Settlement Agreement treats the League’s Black retirees as second-class citizens, or worse, by presuming that their pre-football cognitive abilities were lower than those of their White teammates. This presumption of inferiority is then used to explain away and to avoid paying compensation for Black retirees’ post-football neurocognitive shortfalls. In this way, the NFL has ensured that fewer Black retirees will receive benefits under the Settlement Agreement.”
Henry and Davenport are accusing the League of depriving Black retired players of their equal rights under 42 U.S. Code § 1981. The law mandates that all persons within the United States have the same right to make and enforce contracts.
Meanwhile, NFL spokesperson Brian McCarthy told Law360.com, “The point of such adjustments — in contrast to the complaint’s claims — is to seek to ensure that individuals are treated fairly and compared against comparable groups. But the settlement agreement does not require the use of any particular adjustments, and instead leaves their use to the sound discretion of the independent clinicians administering the tests in any particular case.”
