FOLLOW US

Get ready for a tumultuous year in the world of international trade law, as 2024 unfolds with the promise of legal fireworks. From importers battling a forced labor blacklist to contentious tariff appeals, these cases are the ones to watch, creating a perplexing landscape that keeps trade attorneys on the edge of their seats.

Importers' Section 301 Appeal: A Constitutional Clash

In a legal saga that could rival a gripping courtroom drama, importers are crying foul overreach in their Section 301 appeal. Thousands of companies, embroiled in a battle against sweeping tariffs on Chinese goods, are challenging the president's authority to modify duty programs once set in motion.

International Trade Cases To Watch In 2024 : Constitutional Crisis Looms

The crux of the matter lies in the alleged misuse of Section 301 duties, originally designed to combat unfair trade practices. Importers argue that successive tariff escalations deviated from the prescribed process, leading to a potential constitutional crisis.

John Brew, co-chair of Crowell & Moring LLP's international trade practice group, warns, "Allowing the executive branch to impose tariffs 'when and how it wants' has the potential to create a constitutional crisis."

International Trade Cases To Watch In 2024 : Geopolitical Complications

Adding to the complexity, the growing intertwining of trade policy with geopolitics raises the stakes. Andrew Bisbas of Lowenstein Sandler LLP points out, "If you undermine the ability of the executive [branch] to use what have become kind of accepted foreign policy tools, diplomatic tools, national security tools… I think the appeals court will be hesitant to do that."

Ninestar's Battle Against CBP Evidence Withholding

In a high-stakes showdown reminiscent of a legal thriller, Chinese producers, led by Ninestar, confront the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) over evidence withholding. Accused of ties to Uyghur forced labor, Ninestar fights for justice, echoing a previous victory by a pencil importer.

Virtually Non-Existent Evidence:

Ninestar alleges a lack of substantial evidence behind CBP's actions and highlights the questionable reliance on outdated materials. The case unfolds as Ninestar gains access to investigation records under a judicial protective order.

Commerce's Vietnam Market Review: A Controversial Appraisal

In a politically charged scenario resembling a geopolitical chess match, the U.S. Department of Commerce scrutinizes Vietnam's economy for a potential exit from the nonmarket economy list. However, critics raise concerns about a rushed review with predetermined outcomes.

International Trade Cases To Watch In 2024: Congressional Criticism

Republican senators question the fairness of the review, expressing worries about Vietnam's ties to China and the potential for circumvention and evasion. The case sparks concern among domestic petitioners accusing Vietnamese competitors of dumping or circumvention.

Aluminum Extrusion Probe: A Broad-Scope Nightmare

Enter the world of aluminum extrusion investigations, a labyrinth of legal intricacies reminiscent of a suspenseful thriller. Fifteen countries, including Vietnam, face antidumping and countervailing duty probes, mirroring past challenges that resulted in years of litigation.

Scope Rulings Challenge:

Attorney Andrew Schutz warns of the broad scope of investigations, mirroring past cases that entangled unrelated products. Importers face the nightmare of identifying extruded aluminum parts within larger products, potentially subjecting them to additional duties.